Awards
On record for their credited titles
5
Wins
16
Nominations
21 awards — Alyson Hannigan
×
Teen Choice Awards
9 nominations, 2 won
| TV – Choice Sidekick | Angel · 2002 | Winner |
| TV – Choice Sidekick | Buffy the Vampire Slayer · 2002 | Winner |
| Choice Movie Actress – Comedy | American Reunion · 2012 | Nominee |
| Choice TV Sidekick | Buffy the Vampire Slayer · 2003 | Nominee |
| Choice TV Sidekick | Angel · 2003 | Nominee |
| TV – Choice Sidekick | Buffy the Vampire Slayer · 2001 | Nominee |
| TV – Choice Sidekick | Angel · 2001 | Nominee |
| TV – Choice Sidekick | Angel · 2000 | Nominee |
| TV – Choice Sidekick | Buffy the Vampire Slayer · 2000 | Nominee |
Saturn Awards
6 nominations, 2 won
| Best Supporting Actress on Television | Angel · 2003 | Winner |
| Best Supporting Actress on Television | Buffy the Vampire Slayer · 2003 | Winner |
| Best Supporting Actress on Television | Angel · 2002 | Nominee |
| Best Supporting Actress on Television | Buffy the Vampire Slayer · 2002 | Nominee |
| Best Supporting Actress on Television | Angel · 2001 | Nominee |
| Best Supporting Actress on Television | Buffy the Vampire Slayer · 2001 | Nominee |
People's Choice Awards
2 nominations, 1 won
| Favorite TV Comedy Actress | How I Met Your Mother · 2010 | Winner |
| Favorite TV Comedy Actress | How I Met Your Mother · 2011 | Nominee |
Satellite Awards
2 nominations
| Best Actress in a Supporting Role in a Series, Drama | Buffy the Vampire Slayer · 2003 | Nominee |
| Best Actress in a Supporting Role in a Series, Drama | Angel · 2003 | Nominee |
TV Guide Awards
2 nominations
| Supporting Actress of the Year in a Drama Series | Buffy the Vampire Slayer · 2001 | Nominee |
| Supporting Actress of the Year in a Drama Series | Angel · 2001 | Nominee |
All credits
B
70
Solo Mio
C
62
American Reunion
–
Penn & Teller: Fool Us
F
29
Date Movie
B
70
American Dad!
B
79
How I Met Your Mother
B
79
Veronica Mars
D
59
American Wedding
C
60
American Pie 2
F
44
Boys and Girls
C
65
American Pie
B
78
Angel
D
52
Dead Man on Campus
B
76
That '70s Show
A
83
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
F
44
My Stepmother Is an Alien