Awards
On record for their credited titles
4
Wins
9
Nominations
13 awards — Melissa Benoist
×
Critics' Choice Super Awards
1 nomination
| Best Actress in a Superhero Series | Supergirl · 2021 | Nominee |
Saturn Awards
6 nominations, 2 won
| Best Actress on a Television Series | Supergirl · 2017 | Winner |
| Breakthrough Performance | Supergirl · 2016 | Winner |
| Best Actress on Television | Supergirl · 2021 | Nominee |
| Best Actress on Television | Supergirl · 2019 | Nominee |
| Best Actress on Television | Supergirl · 2016 | Nominee |
| Best Actress on a Television Series | Supergirl · 2018 | Nominee |
Teen Choice Awards
5 nominations, 2 won
| Choice Action TV Actress | Supergirl · 2018 | Winner |
| Choice Action TV Actress | Supergirl · 2017 | Winner |
| Choice Action TV Actress | Supergirl · 2019 | Nominee |
| Choice Liplock | Supergirl · 2017 | Nominee |
| Choice TV Ship | Supergirl · 2017 | Nominee |
Choice TV: Breakout Star
1 nomination
| Choice TV: Breakout Star | Glee · 2013 | Nominee |