The Shop Around the Corner 1940
Anonymous letters offer an escape from the shop's daily negotiations.
Comedy, Drama, Romance · 99 min
The shop is the reason the romance works. Employees worry about money, read the boss's mood and perform friendliness for customers. Alfred and Klara's anonymous letters offer a space outside that daily bargaining, even while their actual encounters keep going wrong. Their problem is wonderfully ordinary: each can imagine a sympathetic stranger more readily than recognise a sympathetic person across the counter.
James Stewart's hesitations and Margaret Sullavan's defensive sharpness stop the premise from becoming a mechanical misunderstanding. A remark can be funny to the room and hurtful to the person it targets. Ernst Lubitsch lets both things happen at once. The supporting employees also have lives that continue when the lovers leave the frame.
The café meeting tests how much that sweetness costs. Alfred discovers the identity of his correspondent before Klara knows his, so their quarrel now contains information he can withhold. Stewart lets his teasing retain a trace of the hurtful colleague, even as he tries to find out whether the affection in the letters might survive acquaintance. Lubitsch does not instantly replace the difficult people with the ideal selves they have written. The ending has something to resolve because the film has allowed fantasy to be kinder than conduct.
Choose this for warmth with some financial anxiety underneath it. Its Christmas setting is an added pleasure, but the sharper subject is the amount of dignity people spend trying to keep a small job. The romance earns its sweetness because the film has noticed that cost.
From 15 critic reviews.
