Full Cast — According to Jim (2001–2009)

Jim Belushi

Jim

Courtney Thorne-Smith

Cheryl

Larry Joe Campbell

Andy

Taylor Atelian

Ruby

Billi Bruno

Gracie

Kimberly Williams-Paisley

Dana

Conner Rayburn

Kyle

Tony Braunagel

Tony

Mitch Rouse

Ryan Gibson

Robert Belushi

Pizza Boy / Ronnie / Guy No. 2 / Playground Bystander / Flight Instructor / Waiter / Older Kyle / Phil

Christopher Moynihan

Chris

Garret Sullivan

Kyle

Connor Sullivan

Kyle

Kathleen Noone

Maggie

Jamison Belushi

Jami / Student #3 / Jami McFame / Little Girl

Bruce Jarchow

Santa / Dr. Zavranski / Gate Keeper / Officer Zavranski / Henry / Phil

John Rubano

John

Jackie Debatin

Mandy

Dan Aykroyd

Danny Michalski

Charlie Hartsock

Charlie / Oliver / Police Officer / Parishioner

Cynthia Stevenson

Cindy

Tim Bagley

Tim

Mo Collins

Emily

Ted Michaels

Kenny

Robin Krieger

Marilyn Crannis

Ed Lover

Ed

Chris Elliott

Reverend Pierson

Jennifer Coolidge

Roxanne

Laraine Newman

Laraine Elkin

Brad Paisley

Eddie / Chad

Michelle Hurd

Kitson

Tammy Townsend

Ms. Crawford

Mark Beltzman

Customer #2 / Fluffy / Beltzman

Kyle Chavarria

Ashley

Ingo Rademacher

Ted

Soleil Borda

Emma

Hira Ambrosino

Sarah

Tim Kazurinsky

Salesman / Elf

Jim Ward

Radio Announcer / Dr. Collins

Wayne Newton

Wayne Newton

Jennifer Candy

Hostess / Marcy (uncredited)

Glen Clark

Glen

Erik Estrada

The Devil / Erik Estrada

Jeff Lewis

Russian Immigrant / Bill

Johnny Lee Schell

Johnny / John

Elizabeth Anne Smith

Sandy

Jeremy Rowley

Waiter #1 / Raggedy Ann

Paul Vinson

Bouncer

Jill Matson-Sachoff

Patty

Grace Rowe

Police Officer

Robert Joseph

Paramedic

Andy Morrow

Jason

Carla Renata

Sherri

Willie Amakye

Willie / Store Clerk

David Pasquesi

Dave

Laurel Green

Bernice