Full Cast — Based on a True Story (2023–2024)

Kaley Cuoco

Ava Bartlett

Chris Messina

Nathan Bartlett

Tom Bateman

Matt Pierce

Liana Liberato

Tory Thompson

Priscilla Quintana

Ruby Gale

June Diane Raphael

Romy Lipinski

Jessica St. Clair

Rochelle Lipinski

Annabelle Dexter-Jones

Serena

Melissa Fumero

Drew

Li Jun Li

Michelle

Aisha Alfa

Carolyn

Sebastian Quinn

Carlos

Alex Alomar Akpobome

Ryan

Brandon Keener

Paul

Miles Mussenden

Detective Quincy Burrell

Aaron Staton

Simon

Kellen Patino

Ollie

Sara Paxton

Chloe's Sister

Belmont Cameli

Mason

Timm Sharp

Richard

Matthew Law

Nick

Natalia Dyer

Chloe Lake

Britney Ortiz

Rebecca

Pierson Fodé

Jamie

Yvonne Senat Jones

Detective Jessie Peterson

Robin Winston

Reporter

Robert Kovacik

Local Newscaster / Male Reporter

Kingston Rumi Southwick

Jaden

Stephanie Allynne

Christa

Rory Scovel

Gustav

Briana Cuoco

Park Mom

Devin Way

Park Dad

Brenda Koo

Park Mom

Audrey Trullinger

Young Woman

Elisa Bocanegra

Georgia

Joe Williamson

Detective Drew Stephens

Josh Archer

Police Officer