Full Cast — I Think You Should Leave with Tim Robinson (2019–2023)

Tim Robinson

Various Characters

Sam Richardson

Baby of the Year Host / Pacific Proposal Parks Owner / Dan

Patti Harrison

Candy / Tracy / Carrie / The Capital Room Investor

Conner O'Malley

Marcus / Rick / Draven / Horny Guy / Robby Star

Tim Heidecker

Gary / Howie / Dr. T

Brandon Wardell

Todd / Party Guest

Will Forte

Old Man on Plane

Artie O'Daly

Alan / Mike

Jessica Parker Kennedy

Megan

Zach Kanin

Andy Samberg

Paul

Jessica Jade Andres

Melissa

Matt Knudsen

John

Fred Willard

New Joe

Cecily Strong

Brenda

Dayna Dooley

Colleen

Lauran September

Dawn

Carmella Riley

Nancy

Whitmer Thomas

Sisa Grey