Full Cast — The Mysterious Benedict Society (2021–2022)

Tony Hale

Nicholas Benedict / Mr. Curtain

Kristen Schaal

Number Two

Mystic Inscho

Reynie Muldoon

Seth Carr

George 'Sticky' Washington

Marta Kessler

Constance Contraire

Emmy DeOliveira

Kate Weatherall

Maameyaa Boafo

Rhonda Kazembe

Ryan Hurst

Milligan

Gia Sandhu

Ms. Perumal

Ben Andrusco-Daon

Isaac

Rémi-Gaël Panon

Student #3

Lex King

Ilsa

Katherine Evans

Jillson

Ben Cockell

Jackson

Gelareh Ghodrati

Student #4

Asia Au-Yeung

Student #1

Sara Bynoe

Spoken Word Teacher

John Gillich

McCabe

Luke Roessler

Nicholas / Nathaniel

Bronson Pinchot