Hidden Gem TV Shows on Metacritic
Brilliant series most people have not found yet. Every title here is rated by at least 5,000 people across every site, enough to trust the score, but by fewer than the 100,000 our main rankings ask for, so none of them can appear there. Ranked by Metacritic alone; the MEANRANK score beside each title is what every site together makes of it.
1
Homicide: Life on the Street
A
88
2
The Thick of It
A
88
3
Rectify
A
87
4
Pachinko
A
88
5
My So-Called Life
A
87
6
My Brilliant Friend
A
88
7
Foyle's War
A
86
8
Pushing Daisies
A
84
9
Somebody Somewhere
A
88
10
The Wonder Years
A
81
11
Mystery Science Theater 3000
A
87
12
Catastrophe
A
86
13
The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance
A
85
14
Everybody Hates Chris
A
81
15
Extras
A
83
16
Undeclared
A
82
17
Better Things
A
84
18
Ed
B
79
19
Party of Five
B
78
20
The Deuce
A
81
21
Rescue Me
A
83
22
Endeavour
A
83
23
The Knick
A
84
24
American Crime
A
83
25
Party Down
A
82
26
Call the Midwife
A
80
27
The Wrong Mans
A
82
28
Southland
A
86
29
Treme
A
84
30
Life on Mars
A
84
31
All Creatures Great & Small
A
86
32
Ghosts
A
85
33
GLOW
B
79
34
Damages
A
83
35
The Missing
A
83
36
Feud
A
80
37
Please Like Me
A
87
38
Terriers
A
85
39
One Hundred Years of Solitude
A
85
40
Felicity
B
75
41
Halt and Catch Fire
A
82
42
Crazy Ex-Girlfriend
A
83
43
In the Flesh
A
85
44
Mr Inbetween
A
85
45
Absolutely Fabulous
A
83
46
The Practice
B
78
47
Masters of Sex
B
77
48
Longmire
A
80
49
Broad City
A
81
50
Widow's Bay
A
86
51
PEN15
A
83
52
Manhattan
A
82
53
The Hour
A
82
54
A Young Doctor's Notebook & Other Stories
B
77
55
The Responder
A
81
56
Aunty Donna's Big Ol' House of Fun
A
80
57
Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip
A
80
58
You're the Worst
A
83
59
Pose
A
82
60
UnREAL
B
79
61
Boss
A
82
62
Farscape
A
81
63
Review
A
85
64
Better Off Ted
A
84
65
Men of a Certain Age
A
81
66
Switched at Birth
B
78
67
Murder, She Wrote
B
79
68
Northern Exposure
A
81
69
Flowers
A
84
70
Dharma & Greg
B
72
71
The Affair
B
76
72
Nashville
B
78
73
Ramy
A
81
74
Gomorrah
A
82
75
Flight of the Conchords
A
84
76
ER
B
76
77
Back to Life
A
82
78
The Baby-Sitters Club
B
79
79
Gavin & Stacey
A
84
80
Interview with the Vampire
A
82
81
The Larry Sanders Show
A
81
82
Tokyo Vice
A
80
83
Awake
B
78
84
Casual
A
80
85
Faking It
B
77
86
Deadloch
A
83
87
State of the Union
B
79
88
On Becoming a God in Central Florida
B
76
89
American Vandal
A
80
90
The Studio
A
80
91
Mozart in the Jungle
A
82
92
I May Destroy You
A
81
93
The Hollow Crown
A
82
94
Colin from Accounts
A
84
95
Scrubs
A
83
96
Death by Lightning
A
81
97
Last Tango in Halifax
A
83
98
Transparent
B
78
99
Looking
A
82
100
My Lady Jane
A
82
Homicide: Life on the Street
A
88
2
The Thick of It
A
88
3
Rectify
A
87
4
Pachinko
A
88
5
My So-Called Life
A
87
6
My Brilliant Friend
A
88
7
Foyle's War
A
86
8
Pushing Daisies
A
84
9
Somebody Somewhere
A
88
10
The Wonder Years
A
81
11
Mystery Science Theater 3000
A
87
12
Catastrophe
A
86
13
The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance
A
85
14
Everybody Hates Chris
A
81
15
Extras
A
83
16
Undeclared
A
82
17
Better Things
A
84
18
Ed
B
79
19
Party of Five
B
78
20
The Deuce
A
81
21
Rescue Me
A
83
22
Endeavour
A
83
23
The Knick
A
84
24
American Crime
A
83
25
Party Down
A
82
26
Call the Midwife
A
80
27
The Wrong Mans
A
82
28
Southland
A
86
29
Treme
A
84
30
Life on Mars
A
84
31
All Creatures Great & Small
A
86
32
Ghosts
A
85
33
GLOW
B
79
34
Damages
A
83
35
The Missing
A
83
36
Feud
A
80
37
Please Like Me
A
87
38
Terriers
A
85
39
One Hundred Years of Solitude
A
85
40
Felicity
B
75
41
Halt and Catch Fire
A
82
42
Crazy Ex-Girlfriend
A
83
43
In the Flesh
A
85
44
Mr Inbetween
A
85
45
Absolutely Fabulous
A
83
46
The Practice
B
78
47
Masters of Sex
B
77
48
Longmire
A
80
49
Broad City
A
81
50
Widow's Bay
A
86
51
PEN15
A
83
52
Manhattan
A
82
53
The Hour
A
82
54
A Young Doctor's Notebook & Other Stories
B
77
55
The Responder
A
81
56
Aunty Donna's Big Ol' House of Fun
A
80
57
Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip
A
80
58
You're the Worst
A
83
59
Pose
A
82
60
UnREAL
B
79
61
Boss
A
82
62
Farscape
A
81
63
Review
A
85
64
Better Off Ted
A
84
65
Men of a Certain Age
A
81
66
Switched at Birth
B
78
67
Murder, She Wrote
B
79
68
Northern Exposure
A
81
69
Flowers
A
84
70
Dharma & Greg
B
72
71
The Affair
B
76
72
Nashville
B
78
73
Ramy
A
81
74
Gomorrah
A
82
75
Flight of the Conchords
A
84
76
ER
B
76
77
Back to Life
A
82
78
The Baby-Sitters Club
B
79
79
Gavin & Stacey
A
84
80
Interview with the Vampire
A
82
81
The Larry Sanders Show
A
81
82
Tokyo Vice
A
80
83
Awake
B
78
84
Casual
A
80
85
Faking It
B
77
86
Deadloch
A
83
87
State of the Union
B
79
88
On Becoming a God in Central Florida
B
76
89
American Vandal
A
80
90
The Studio
A
80
91
Mozart in the Jungle
A
82
92
I May Destroy You
A
81
93
The Hollow Crown
A
82
94
Colin from Accounts
A
84
95
Scrubs
A
83
96
Death by Lightning
A
81
97
Last Tango in Halifax
A
83
98
Transparent
B
78
99
Looking
A
82
100
My Lady Jane
A
82