9 October 2026

Highest-rated sitcoms by Metacritic users: scores with the samples attached

Twenty-five stored user scores. Small tallies stay visible, ties stay ties, and the recommendations concern the comedy rather than voter stereotypes.

25 entries

I'm Alan Partridge and BoJack Horseman make a useful opening comparison. The former's source tally in this edition is very small; the latter's is much larger. Read those counts before treating a difference in the displayed scores as a reliable ordering of television history.

This is a list of 25 high stored Metacritic user scores among eligible sitcoms in MEANRANK's curated field. It is not Metacritic's official chart, a survey of all viewers or an independent measurement of which programme is best.

Metacritic separates the user score from the professional-review Metascore. Its support explanation states that user votes do not enter the Metascore. The two figures therefore describe different inputs, not two interchangeable units of the same judgement.

For this edition, a known stored tally of 20 source voters was sufficient for consideration. Eligible titles also needed 5,000 recorded votes across the catalogue's sources. That second requirement does not make twenty Metacritic voters a large sample, and adding counts across sites does not produce a unique-person total.

A higher score can rest on far fewer recorded voters

ProgrammeSaved user scoreRecorded source voters
I'm Alan Partridge9.5/1020
Yes Minister9.4/1023
BoJack Horseman8.8/102,880

The difference is substantial enough to belong in the argument, not in small print. This selection puts the larger user score first. It does not claim that twenty responses have settled a contest against thousands. Nor does it establish that the smaller group's taste is more refined, more nostalgic or more intense.

The permissive rule allows small records to appear; it does not certify their stability. The count printed beneath each score is part of the result. A larger tally is useful evidence about quantity, but still does not turn a self-selecting set of voters into a representative public sample.

Edition compiled: 30 October 2026. The values are catalogue records, with uneven source observation dates and television season coverage. Equal displayed scores are ties at that precision. Position numbers should not be used to claim a preference the visible values do not establish.

MEANRANK's accompanying aggregate may include the same user score, so it is not an independent countervote. The notes below offer a reason to try each programme without inventing a personality shared by everyone who used this platform.

Episode examples contain spoilers. The criticism below gives the numbers something particular to lead toward; it does not claim to recover the reasons behind the votes.

How this is judged

Metacritic's users computed
The rating from Metacritic's users, on its own scale.
MEANRANK computed
Every rating we hold for the show, on one scale.

Computed scores come straight from the ratings, so you can check them. Editorial ones are our opinion, and every one comes with the reason for it.

1

I'm Alan Partridge 1997–2002

Comedy · 30 min episodes

A 88

Alan's explanation of his position keeps revealing the insecurity it is meant to conceal. Steve Coogan makes a small adjustment in status feel urgent without making the character understand why it is funny. The very small recorded source tally is especially important to this entry's numerical position.

Alan's need to be recognised has an immediate audience: a receptionist, a colleague or someone whose ordinary day his request is interrupting. The performance becomes painful because a small refusal can expose how much he hoped the encounter would establish. Coogan does not need the other person to be cruel. Their failure to share his scale of importance is enough.

Metacritic's users computed
9.5/10

From 20 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
88/100

From 3 ratings.

2

Yes Minister 1980–1982

Comedy, War · 30 min episodes

A+ 90

The minister wants a decision to remain clear long enough to enact it. Sir Humphrey's language makes other definitions of responsibility appear unavoidable. Watch the moment an explanation stops helping its listener understand and begins changing what the listener believes can be done.

Hacker's political appetite keeps the satire from becoming an account of a purely public-spirited man defeated by bad officials. A convenient headline or a protected position can be a reason he accepts an argument he partly sees through. The pleasure of Humphrey's persuasion includes recognising the part of the listener already prepared to cooperate.

Metacritic's users computed
9.4/10

From 23 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
90/100

From 4 ratings.

3

Mr. Bean 1990–1995

Comedy, Family · 25 min episodes

A 85

The task is usually easy to recognise; the solution becomes absurdly personal. Bean's insistence makes the object or social rule seem to have failed him. The physical timing needs a clear objective so that a small deviation can accumulate into an increasingly unreasonable arrangement.

His attempt to change on a beach makes privacy a physical puzzle. Another person's presence is a condition he must account for, not simply background to a solitary routine. Concealment requires a sequence of movements whose difficulty remains visible. Atkinson gives the audience a clear objective and lets the chosen route become the mistake.

Metacritic's users computed
9.0/10

From 64 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
86/100

From 7 ratings.

4

The Golden Girls 1985–1992

Comedy, Drama · 30 min episodes

A 81

A shared home brings different experiences of marriage, work and independence into the same conversation. The replies matter because none of the women permanently owns the sensible position. Care remains possible after an assumption has been sharply corrected.

The household gives each woman a position beyond receiving the others' advice. A desire for companionship, money or another chance at intimacy can conflict with the arrangement that keeps the home workable. The sharp reply is more satisfying when it comes from someone with a stake. The women are funny participants rather than representatives distributing lessons about age.

Metacritic's users computed
9.0/10

From 62 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
81/100

From 7 ratings.

5

Seinfeld 1989–1998

Comedy · 22 min episodes

A 86

The convergence is part of the joke. A small evasion in one story can arrive elsewhere as a practical catastrophe. The audience has enough information to see the connection before the character can. Precision turns apparently minor behaviour into an exact social mechanism.

“The Opposite” makes George's desire to improve his life into a rule he can apply with suspicious ease. An apparently successful new strategy does not mean that self-interest has vanished. The episode is funny because a different account can reorganise behaviour without producing moral renewal. It puts the wish for a fresh start beside the attraction of a shortcut.

Metacritic's users computed
8.9/10

From 819 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
86/100

From 9 ratings.

6

BoJack Horseman 2014–2020

Animation, Comedy, Drama · 25 min episodes

A 87

BoJack can produce a fluent account of why he hurts people. The programme is strongest when the account does not purchase the response he wants. Comic absurdity makes the self-excuse attractive before memory, another person's need and a continuing relationship make it inadequate.

Another person's refusal to forgive need not be a puzzle the protagonist is entitled to solve. That is where the show's serial memory matters most. A disclosure may change how an act is understood without returning the relationship to its previous terms. The comedy allows the self-serving explanation to be attractive enough that its failure still hurts.

Metacritic's users computed
8.8/10

From 2,880 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
88/100

From 9 ratings.

7

Friends 1994–2004

Comedy, Romance · 22 min episodes

A 83

The group is an audience for each member's attempted self-description. Familiarity gives a look or a delayed reply more information than the line alone contains. Repetition can deepen that resource or overuse it; a high user score cannot decide which particular romantic cycle has earned another return.

A romance is difficult to end cleanly when both people still belong to the same small group. The coffeehouse can provide comfort and make avoidance impossible in the same scene. The continuing arrangement gives a small remark disproportionate force. It is more interesting where the friends have competing needs than where they function chiefly as an audience for the next romantic development.

Metacritic's users computed
8.8/10

From 2,306 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
83/100

From 10 ratings.

8

Arrested Development 2003–2019

Comedy · 22 min episodes

A 82

The Bluths explain behaviour through accounts that their own evidence keeps undermining. A detail can be preparation, a background joke and a later correction to what we thought happened. The density rewards attention, while also asking whether the current scene has life beyond its machinery.

First viewing and rewatching offer different pleasures. Initially, a detail can be available without its significance; later, the viewer can see how an apparently spontaneous turn was prepared. The important test is whether the current scene still has friction between people. A perfect callback is a smaller achievement if everyone has become only a mechanism for delivering it.

Metacritic's users computed
8.8/10

From 1,541 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
82/100

From 9 ratings.

9

Cheers 1982–1993

Comedy, Drama · 22 min episodes

A 80

Sam's bar promises company without guaranteeing the particular recognition somebody wants. Regulars know enough to puncture an attractive account. The comedy is richest when the puncture does not erase the need that produced it, or the practical reason people continue to return.

Sam's history makes the refuge less innocent than a room where everybody knows a name. Charm and familiarity have uses in a life already marked by losses. A regular's refusal to accept a flattering account can therefore be part of belonging rather than its opposite. The series is richest when comfort still permits an unwelcome truth.

Metacritic's users computed
8.8/10

From 95 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
81/100

From 8 ratings.

10

Boy Meets World 1993–2000

Comedy, Drama, Family · 23 min episodes

B 74

The recurring authority figures create a history against which a young person's new certainty can be tested. Learning is more persuasive when it alters the next interaction, rather than arriving solely as a closing explanation. The friendships matter because growth does not happen at the same speed for everybody.

Cory and Shawn's friendship cannot remove the difference between their home circumstances. Advice that seems obvious from one household may require resources or security the other cannot assume. The programme earns an emotional resolution where familiarity makes that difference harder to ignore. A reassuring speech is less adequate if the practical condition remains unacknowledged.

Metacritic's users computed
8.8/10

From 91 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
74/100

From 7 ratings.

11

Daria 1997–2001

Animation, Comedy, Drama · 30 min episodes

A 86

An accurate joke can protect its maker from admitting a less manageable feeling. Jane gives that defence a relationship capable of answering it. The programme does not need Daria to stop being intelligent; it needs intelligence to remain compatible with being wrong about another person.

Daria's independence is partly an account she performs for people whose approval she claims not to need. The show can preserve her valid objection to a school ritual while revealing an interest she would rather not admit. The contradiction gives the dry delivery movement. A permanent position above everybody else would leave the heroine with far less to do.

Metacritic's users computed
8.8/10

From 74 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
86/100

From 4 ratings.

12

M*A*S*H 1972–1983

Comedy, Drama, War · 25 min episodes

A 80

Comic routines take place inside work whose consequences cannot be made harmless. The shift into grief is stronger when it grows from a relationship the jokes have already established. The series changes over time; a stored user score does not identify which period supplied a particular voter's judgement.

The Korean War setting places the doctors inside an institution whose immediate demands they cannot vote away through a good argument. Competence is necessary and insufficient. A successful operation can coexist with anger about the system supplying the next patient. The recurring workplace gives that contradiction duration instead of resolving it through one exemplary act of care.

Metacritic's users computed
8.8/10

From 38 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
81/100

From 7 ratings.

13

Community 2009–2015

Comedy · 22 min episodes

A 83

The genre experiment works when it gives a member of the study group a new way to expose an old need. A familiar form can turn campus life into an action film or a game, while the ordinary problem of belonging remains unresolved beneath the change of costume.

“Cooperative Calligraphy” makes a missing pen the basis of a dispute about trust and privacy. A small object matters because each person experiences the search through an accumulated place in the group. The bottle setting removes the usual exits. The study room has to sustain a whole argument without another genre arriving to enlarge it.

Metacritic's users computed
8.7/10

From 2,224 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
84/100

From 9 ratings.

14

It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia 2005

Comedy · 22 min episodes

A 85

The group can turn a self-serving impulse into a complete theory of fairness. Agreement then makes the theory more destructive. The dark comedy depends on recognising the rationalisation without requiring an innocent character to explain the lesson after every consequence.

The outsiders need intelligible claims for the satire to have resistance. Someone may want payment, competent work or the Gang to stop appropriating an occasion. Those ordinary demands expose the terms of the group's self-description. When everyone outside it becomes equally disposable, another escalation can be less revealing than the first bad excuse.

Metacritic's users computed
8.7/10

From 1,631 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
85/100

From 9 ratings.

15

Futurama 1999–2026

Adventure, Animation, Comedy · 22 min episodes

A 82

Time, space and technology let an ordinary missed opportunity acquire enormous physical scale. The ensemble keeps that scale emotionally legible. A machine can change the available world without making Fry, Leela or Bender better at asking another person for what they need.

“The Luck of the Fryrish” lets Fry interpret evidence through a grievance he brought from another time. The episode can make his anger understandable and his account incomplete. Science fiction supplies distance from the past, while memory gives the distance a personal object. The eventual feeling depends on the arrangement of information, not merely the addition of a sad disclosure.

Metacritic's users computed
8.7/10

From 1,133 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
83/100

From 9 ratings.

16

Malcolm in the Middle 2000–2006

Comedy, Family · 22 min episodes

A 83

Being the clever child does not let Malcolm stand outside his family's constraints or his own vanity. His direct address gives the audience a defence the action may immediately complicate. Intelligence is a resource and another way to misunderstand what matters in the room.

The special treatment attached to being gifted can benefit Malcolm while making him feel conspicuously separate. The family does not have to deny his ability for that distinction to create another kind of vanity. His narration becomes more revealing where a defensible complaint also hides an appetite for recognition. The clever observer still wants the room to organise itself around him.

Metacritic's users computed
8.7/10

From 399 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
83/100

From 8 ratings.

17

Spaced 1999–2001

Comedy · 25 min episodes

A 86

The shared flat contains people with different ambitions and overlapping imaginative references. Style becomes useful when it changes how an ordinary event is felt. The fake relationship that secures the accommodation cannot automatically supply the trust required to live together.

A reference can let Tim turn an ordinary setback into an event with familiar dramatic rules. Daisy and the others still need to live with the practical consequences after the imagined genre has passed. The contrast gives the style a limit. Shared taste creates a language for intimacy without supplying all the habits on which intimacy depends.

Metacritic's users computed
8.7/10

From 72 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
87/100

From 7 ratings.

18

The IT Crowd 2006–2010

Comedy · 25 min episodes

A 82

The office's technical dependence creates an odd reversal: the people with necessary expertise can still have little social authority. Roy, Moss and Jen need one another's abilities while continually misunderstanding their value. The broad situations work best when that dependence remains active.

“The Speech” gives technical authority a portable object other people can admire without understanding. The deception works because the room already wants confidence in a presentable form. Roy and Moss know enough to create the absurdity, but expertise does not give them complete control of its reception. The joke reaches beyond a supposedly ignorant manager.

Metacritic's users computed
8.6/10

From 289 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
83/100

From 9 ratings.

19

Peep Show 2003–2015

Comedy · 25 min episodes

A 86

The internal voice offers a reason; the image supplies what the reason leaves out. The viewer receives both without becoming obliged to accept the explanation. Mark and Jeremy can be perceptive about a failure and still protect the habit that will produce the next one.

A thought can move from observation to self-protection before the character has finished the sentence aloud. That speed is the invention. The viewer need not possess a better private life to recognise the movement. The embarrassment grows because the explanation is close enough to an ordinary defence to be intelligible, even when the resulting action is vicious.

Metacritic's users computed
8.6/10

From 204 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
87/100

From 7 ratings.

20

The King of Queens 1998–2007

Comedy · 22 min episodes

C 69

A small household convenience becomes a negotiation about the marriage's terms. Doug and Carrie's tactics are more revealing than a simple distribution of sensible and foolish roles. Arthur gives the couple another claim they cannot settle merely by agreeing with each other.

Carrie's office and Doug's delivery work give the marriage different daily audiences and sources of embarrassment. A favour can matter because one spouse must now appear a certain way before colleagues the other rarely sees. Their familiar domestic tactics acquire another cost in public. The comedy has more texture when neither workplace exists solely to validate one partner's complaint.

Metacritic's users computed
8.6/10

From 118 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
70/100

From 7 ratings.

21

Corner Gas 2004–2009

Comedy · 30 min episodes

A 83

The routines around a Saskatchewan gas station and neighbouring diner give minor local distinctions the force their owners attach to them. The comedy needs the town to remain specific without asking every small dispute to become a sentimental lesson about community.

Brent's familiarity with the station and Lacey's investment in the diner give neighbouring businesses different kinds of attention. A newcomer can regard a local habit as something to improve, while a resident can hear the proposed improvement as a judgment. The stakes remain small enough for a phrase to matter. Community need not become a lesson for either side to win.

Metacritic's users computed
8.6/10

From 21 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
83/100

From 3 ratings.

22

Parks and Recreation 2009–2015

Comedy · 22 min episodes

A 83

Leslie's commitment can produce useful work and an overconfident idea of what other people need. Ron's resistance can expose waste and evade responsibility. The institution becomes interesting when those positions have practical consequences rather than remaining attractive personality labels.

A public project requires something beyond agreement among the people the audience already likes. Residents can have inconvenient preferences; a meeting can be frustrating without every objection being worthless. The programme is sharper when Leslie's commitment has to answer those people. Warmth becomes less demanding where affection inside the office reliably guarantees the correctness of its plans.

Metacritic's users computed
8.5/10

From 1,657 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
83/100

From 9 ratings.

23

Silicon Valley 2014–2019

Comedy · 30 min episodes

A 85

The team can solve the technical problem while worsening the ownership, financial or social one. Competence therefore remains partial. The best reversals follow from interests that cannot all be satisfied, not from the premise that every success must be cancelled by another arbitrary disaster.

Dinesh and Gilfoyle give technical work an internal hierarchy of pride. They can need each other's competence while treating recognition as scarce. Richard's founder story is therefore not the only account of the enterprise. A good ensemble scene lets a colleague's contribution become necessary without obliging everyone else to like the person making it.

Metacritic's users computed
8.5/10

From 1,356 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
86/100

From 9 ratings.

24

Scrubs 2001–2010

Comedy, Drama · 30 min episodes

A 81

JD's imagination offers an escape from the immediate scene and a revealing account of what he cannot comfortably admit within it. The hospital's work gives that inwardness a limit. A strong comic fantasy changes our understanding of the response he must still make to a real person.

J.D.'s self-description is not identical to the hospital's need. A patient or colleague may require a practical response while he is organising a private story about being recognised, forgiven or unusually compassionate. The fantasy becomes useful where returning from it changes that response. The voice is less revealing when it simply awards him the lesson he hoped to learn.

Metacritic's users computed
8.5/10

From 866 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
81/100

From 9 ratings.

25

Curb Your Enthusiasm 2000–2024

Comedy · 30 min episodes

A 86

Larry's grievance can have an intelligible basis while the effort to prove it causes greater damage. Social rules appear negotiable until another person insists on a different account. The comedy depends on keeping that other position available, even when the lead's explanation is the louder one.

The person resisting Larry should possess more than the function of being offended. Their work, inconvenience or conflicting understanding gives the dispute a second centre. The series is better when both positions remain readable than when every collision demonstrates that he saw through another foolish convention. Social comedy needs a world capable of answering back.

Metacritic's users computed
8.5/10

From 746 Metacritic users.

MEANRANK computed
86/100

From 9 ratings.

Where this comes from: Metacritic: the user score and Metascore are separate

A useful recommendation needs more than a lead

Partridge's embarrassment, Yes Minister's procedural language and Mr. Bean's physical problem-solving are different attractions. Their scores cannot tell you which form of attention you want to spend an evening giving.

I would start with the mechanism. Do you want a person explaining himself while the images contradict him? Try Peep Show. Do you want a community whose administrative work becomes an argument about commitment? Try Parks and Recreation. Do you want a family or friendship whose old habits give a small reply its weight? Several of the ensembles here offer that, in sharply different tones.

Then use the count to decide how much to ask of the number. A tiny tally can identify enthusiasm worth investigating without establishing a robust placement. A large tally can still be selective.

The purpose of showing the sample is to keep those two ideas together. We need not hide the high score, and we need not pretend it has said more than it has.

For the separate professional-review measure, see the stored Metascore list.

← All lists