9 October 2026

Highest-rated sitcoms on Metacritic: the stored critic scores

Twenty-five Metascores from the catalogue, with review counts and a clear distinction between a season, a whole series and an approval percentage.

25 entries

Read the year beside The Office. The 2001 British programme and the 2005 American programme are different records, not two labels for one score. Read the review count as well: a high value based on a handful of notices has a different evidential base from one supported by many more.

This page orders 25 eligible sitcom records by the Metascore stored in MEANRANK. It is a catalogue selection, not Metacritic's own official all-time chart and not a fresh collection of every review published today.

Metacritic defines the Metascore as a weighted aggregate of included professional reviews. A 90 Metascore is not the claim that 90% of critics approved. That second kind of question belongs to an approval measure such as the Tomatometer.

Television introduces another distinction. Metacritic publishes season-specific material as well as title pages. Our stored record does not provide a uniform, independently verified account of which seasons contribute to every value here. A single number should therefore not be described automatically as a first-season score, a complete-run average or proof of the best final season.

Edition compiled: 30 October 2026. Eligibility used a known stored Metacritic review count of at least four and 5,000 recorded votes across catalogue sources. Four is a permissive inclusion threshold, not a guarantee of stability. Votes elsewhere do not enlarge this critic sample.

Two high scores with very different review counts

The British Office leads this selection at 97 from 47 recorded critic reviews. The Thick of It has 92 from five. Both meet this edition's threshold, but meeting a threshold does not make their evidential bases equivalent. The score and count are saved catalogue observations; neither supplies the missing season history.

Those five reviews should not be mistaken for five votes on every episode ever made. Nor does a larger count guarantee agreement among the included critics. To assess a particular season, open its reviews and ask what work they actually cover.

Equal displayed scores are ties at the shown precision. Entry numbers provide a reading order; they do not establish a meaningful distinction between equal values. The accompanying MEANRANK score can include the Metascore itself, so it is context rather than an independent verdict from the rest of the world.

The brief notes give a reason to try the work. They are our criticism, not paraphrases attributed to the included reviewers.

Episode examples below contain spoilers. The notes examine construction and performance; they do not attribute those arguments to the reviewers whose scores formed the Metascore.

How this is judged

Metacritic's critics computed
The rating from Metacritic's critics, on its own scale.
MEANRANK computed
Every rating we hold for the show, on one scale.

Computed scores come straight from the ratings, so you can check them. Editorial ones are our opinion, and every one comes with the reason for it.

1

The Office 2001–2002

Comedy · 30 min episodes

A 85

The 2001 British series makes a camera into an opportunity Brent cannot stop trying to use. His corrections to an impression repeatedly worsen it. The humour depends on performance under observation, not simply on a workplace containing embarrassing people. The year distinguishes this record from the American adaptation.

A reaction shot can withhold the response Brent is trying to obtain. The viewer understands both why a worker remains silent and why the silence fails to correct him. That is a precise dramatic arrangement: a person possesses enough knowledge to see the problem, without possessing the freedom to state it safely to the person who controls the occasion.

Metacritic's critics computed
97/100

From 47 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
85/100

From 8 ratings.

2

The Larry Sanders Show 1992–1998

Comedy · 30 min episodes

A 81

A good interview can leave the host privately dissatisfied. The broadcast needs entertainment; Larry needs reassurance, status and control. The tension between those objectives makes a backstage conversation alter what the audience thought it saw on camera.

The camera's change of setting changes the rules of a face. A host can offer effortless interest during a broadcast, then inspect an innocuous remark afterward for evidence of disrespect. Shandling does not need a completely different private personality. A small change in the use of attention can expose what the public ease was designed to obtain.

Metacritic's critics computed
95/100

From 69 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
82/100

From 6 ratings.

3

The Thick of It 2005–2012

Comedy · 30 min episodes

A 88

A policy announcement becomes a struggle over which account can survive the next call. Language is not decoration around the action. It changes what can be denied, explained or blamed. Read the modest review count with the high score rather than treating either as the complete recommendation.

An open door means that somebody may arrive before the current account has been secured. The handheld camera can make information feel like a physical intrusion, not simply a line delivered to advance the plot. People must keep making decisions while waiting to discover what those decisions now mean. The formal nervousness has a task underneath it.

Metacritic's critics computed
92/100

From 5 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
88/100

From 5 ratings.

4

Everybody Hates Chris 2005–2009

Comedy, Drama, Music · 22 min episodes

A 81

Adult narration gives an adolescent incident a second perspective without necessarily relieving the child of it. The family and school make dignity practical: another person may control the rule, the money or the account of what happened. Humiliation can be comic without becoming harmless.

The narrated exaggeration needs an immediate event to push against. A rule can be described grandly while the child is dealing with the small practical matter of getting through a corridor or answering an adult. The change of scale lets humour identify a pattern without giving young Chris the knowledge or power to remove it.

Metacritic's critics computed
88/100

From 32 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
81/100

From 7 ratings.

5

Malcolm in the Middle 2000–2006

Comedy, Family · 22 min episodes

A 83

Malcolm's address to the camera gives him an argument before the household has finished supplying evidence against it. Intelligence does not make him independent of his own vanity. The family remains a physical and economic system that a clever explanation cannot simply escape.

The adults prevent the clever-child perspective from settling the whole programme. Lois can be unreasonable in a particular exchange while still managing labour the children fail to count; Hal can create chaos from an appetite wholly his own. The ensemble gives Malcolm resistance. His intelligence has to remain one instrument inside a household rather than its final interpretation.

Metacritic's critics computed
88/100

From 26 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
83/100

From 8 ratings.

6

PEN15 2019–2021

Comedy · 30 min episodes

A 83

The adult leads do not grant their younger selves adult understanding. A social slight can become enormous while the audience recognises the disproportion. The comedy is especially effective when tenderness does not require making the adolescent behaviour wiser or nicer than it was.

The surrounding young performers are essential to the casting device. The adult leads cannot rely on everybody else playing a retrospective joke with them. A small social refusal retains an ordinary child's scale while Maya or Anna experiences it as overwhelming. The incongruity makes an adolescent feeling visible without making the other children imaginary monsters.

Metacritic's critics computed
87/100

From 36 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
83/100

From 6 ratings.

7

Modern Family 2009–2020

Comedy, Drama, Romance · 22 min episodes

A 82

The interviews give each person a preferred account; the family interactions then test it. A joke can arise from the delay between those two versions. The form is stronger when a response changes the account than when the interview simply explains a punchline we already understood.

The space between interview and action is the important cut. A parent can announce a generous motive and then reveal the qualification they have withheld from themselves. If both shots merely repeat the same information, the form becomes commentary on an already completed joke. The sharper version lets the second account surprise the first.

Metacritic's critics computed
87/100

From 30 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
83/100

From 9 ratings.

8

The Simpsons 1989

Animation, Comedy · 22 min episodes

A 80

A town allows different institutions to organise the comedy without losing the family at the centre. The stored Metascore should not be used to explain every period of a very long run. Choose a season or episode for a claim about the writing in that period.

“Bart Gets an F” makes a familiar troublemaker's effort matter without suddenly awarding him a new personality. Failure threatens something he actually wants, and the comic habits remain present while the stakes become painful. The ending has force because the episode has distinguished failing to care from trying and still being unable to do enough.

Metacritic's critics computed
87/100

From 16 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
80/100

From 8 ratings.

9

Curb Your Enthusiasm 2000–2024

Comedy · 30 min episodes

A 86

A small etiquette dispute can become a contest over who is entitled to define the rule. Larry's explanation is often coherent and still socially destructive. The escalation works best when the audience can understand both the grievance and the reason another person refuses its terms.

A planted detail is strongest when its return alters a relationship, not merely when the audience remembers it. A rule Larry wanted enforced can acquire a new claimant whose situation exposes what the first version conveniently excluded. The payoff has an argument inside its neatness. His own explanation has supplied the terms on which it can now be challenged.

Metacritic's critics computed
84/100

From 130 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
86/100

From 9 ratings.

10

Silicon Valley 2014–2019

Comedy · 30 min episodes

A 85

Knowing how to build something does not settle who owns it, how to sell it or which compromise will keep the company alive. The comic reversals are sharpest when a technically successful choice creates a different institutional problem, rather than when another random disaster simply postpones success.

A demonstration has two tests: whether the technology works and whether the people controlling the next stage understand it as something worth backing. The scene can satisfy the first and fail the second for an intelligible reason. That split gives the satire a productive object. Expertise matters, while remaining insufficient to command the institution built around it.

Metacritic's critics computed
84/100

From 79 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
86/100

From 9 ratings.

11

Rick and Morty 2013

Action, Adventure, Animation · 23 min episodes

A 85

The science-fiction device is most useful when it exposes an evasion. A person can cross realities and remain unable to answer an ordinary family demand. The programme's inventiveness deserves scrutiny alongside its tendency to make the most capable person appear entitled to define the terms.

“Total Rickall” turns affectionate memory into unreliable evidence of belonging. A family scene's familiar emotional signals have become part of the threat. The invention earns its complexity by changing how the audience reads an apparently reassuring exchange. It also gives the eventual joke a cost: certainty about another person is harder to recover than a room's ordinary appearance.

Metacritic's critics computed
84/100

From 38 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
86/100

From 9 ratings.

12

Seinfeld 1989–1998

Comedy · 22 min episodes

A 86

Small private evasions become public collisions. The converging plots give trivial decisions consequences the people making them could not foresee. The precision is in the relationship between the threads, not a claim that a show about ordinary irritations literally contains no subject.

“The Contest” gets substantial movement from an arrangement the characters have imposed on themselves. A glance, a report or someone's sudden absence changes what the others believe about the competition. The restraint in what is explicitly shown gives reaction more work. A deliberately narrow premise becomes an ensemble structure rather than a single joke prolonged.

Metacritic's critics computed
84/100

From 16 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
86/100

From 9 ratings.

13

What We Do in the Shadows 2019–2024

Comedy, Fantasy, Horror · 30 min episodes

A 84

Immortality does not produce maturity. The household can survive centuries and remain unable to conduct a useful meeting. The documentary device lets an extravagant account of supernatural power encounter the small practical indignities of sharing space.

The vampire council gives supernatural rank a bureaucratic form. Extraordinary beings still need procedure, witnesses and a convincing account of what happened. The housemates' preferred grandeur encounters people who do not automatically accept it. The satire works through that resistance, rather than only through putting ancient costumes beside a modern object.

Metacritic's critics computed
83/100

From 79 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
84/100

From 8 ratings.

14

Extras 2005–2006

Comedy, Drama · 30 min episodes

A 83

An opportunity to be noticed can make a conversation impossible to keep ordinary. The famous guest's image matters when it changes what Andy believes he can obtain or safely say. Recognition alone is not the joke; the attempt to use recognition creates it.

A celebrity guest supplies a version of a public image the scene can use against Andy's expectations. The character's fame changes how freely he can answer an inappropriate remark or decline a demand. The performance is fiction, not evidence about the guest's private life. Its critical value lies in making professional dependence active inside a seemingly casual conversation.

Metacritic's critics computed
83/100

From 50 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
83/100

From 8 ratings.

15

Veep 2012–2019

Comedy, War · 30 min episodes

A 83

A public position and a private objective rarely remain aligned. The staff must make a usable statement while protecting their own future within the institution. The speed works because the interests are distinct, even when everybody wants to call the same action loyalty.

“Testimony” gives the characters a record they cannot entirely rewrite. An official question asks for one usable answer, while their established survival habits keep generating qualifications and blame. The hearing changes the tempo of the usual workplace evasion. A sentence has to survive another person being entitled to ask what it actually means.

Metacritic's critics computed
82/100

From 115 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
83/100

From 8 ratings.

16

BoJack Horseman 2014–2020

Animation, Comedy, Drama · 25 min episodes

A 87

The old sitcom promises a lesson and a reset; BoJack's life keeps remembering the injury after the lesson has been articulated. The comic world makes that contradiction enjoyable before it becomes painful. A single stored critic aggregate cannot describe the response to every stage of the development.

“Free Churro” makes a sustained speech carry the difficulty of not receiving a reply. An audience can be present without supplying the particular recognition the speaker wants. The form exposes the temptation to use another person's absence to complete one's own account. Its verbal brilliance remains uncomfortable because eloquence has not solved the need underneath it.

Metacritic's critics computed
82/100

From 57 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
88/100

From 9 ratings.

17

The Good Place 2016–2020

Comedy, Drama, Fantasy · 22 min episodes

A 84

The premise makes ethical reasoning a practical problem rather than only a subject for a final speech. People have to cooperate while their motives and information change. The comedy is strongest when a proposed rule creates a new difficulty the characters must actually inhabit.

The trolley problem becomes more than an example to explain when a character must confront its consequences as an experience. The series can expose the distance between giving a defensible answer and continuing to live with what the answer entails. The comedy depends on keeping that human resistance available after the concept has been named.

Metacritic's critics computed
82/100

From 48 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
84/100

From 9 ratings.

18

Broad City 2014–2019

Comedy, Drama · 22 min episodes

A 81

Abbi and Ilana can turn an errand into a performance of who they want to be. Their friendship supplies help and further trouble, often in the same gesture. The city is useful because confidence cannot make its practical resistance disappear.

The city supplies clocks, queues, limited money and people who do not owe the friends an accommodating response. That resistance lets an extravagant private account become a concrete problem. Ilana's confidence is useful until it becomes another demand Abbi must manage. The friendship has comic movement because support and interference can arrive through the same gesture.

Metacritic's critics computed
82/100

From 39 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
82/100

From 7 ratings.

19

Big Mouth 2017–2025

Animation, Comedy, Romance · 30 min episodes

B 74

The personified impulse is a formal tool, not an automatic guarantee of candour. It works when competing voices make a particular embarrassment clearer. The explicitness is substantial, and a viewer can understand the device while deciding that its balance of observation and provocation is unwelcome.

The monster must remain a dramatic participant, not a complete excuse. A feeling can speak persuasively and still lead a child into conduct another person experiences as an injury. The device earns its frankness where the consequence reaches the relationship outside the fantasy. Simply enlarging the image of an impulse is a less demanding achievement.

Metacritic's critics computed
82/100

From 36 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
74/100

From 8 ratings.

20

The Golden Girls 1985–1992

Comedy, Drama · 30 min episodes

A 81

The household brings different histories into the same immediate problem. A resident's confident advice can be corrected by another woman's experience. The comedy depends on those responses remaining distinct, while the practical obligation to care survives the argument.

The staging can keep all four responses available while only one woman is telling the story. A listener's patience, scepticism or eagerness to take a turn gives the line more than one destination. The joke is not complete at the moment it is spoken. An exact delay can let affection and irritation become visible together.

Metacritic's critics computed
82/100

From 6 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
81/100

From 7 ratings.

21

Cheers 1982–1993

Comedy, Drama · 22 min episodes

A 80

A familiar bar creates an audience for a person's account of the day. Someone who remembers yesterday's version can change the meaning of today's line. The ensemble makes familiarity active: a recurring response has to remain particular, rather than merely reassure us that the regulars have returned.

The workplace matters to Sam and Diane's argument. Being verbally superior does not automatically make someone good at service, and running the room does not make someone perceptive about every person inside it. Each can encounter a form of competence they would prefer to dismiss. Attraction has a practical world in which to become more complicated.

Metacritic's critics computed
81/100

From 17 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
81/100

From 8 ratings.

22

Ghosts 2019–2023

Comedy, Fantasy, Sci-Fi · 30 min episodes

A 85

This is the 2019 British series. A house contains people whose habits belong to incompatible periods, while the living occupants need to use it now. The premise is strongest when a small domestic objective gives the different histories something specific to interrupt.

Visibility gives the blocking a rule. Alison must address somebody whose position Mike cannot independently verify; the audience can see why the same moment supplies incompatible experiences. A scene therefore need not explain every misunderstanding aloud. The invented condition changes an ordinary couple's distribution of attention and work.

Metacritic's critics computed
81/100

From 10 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
86/100

From 6 ratings.

23

Absolutely Fabulous 1992–2012

Comedy · 45 min episodes

A 83

Edina and Patsy treat self-indulgence as evidence of sophistication. Saffy's practical objections expose the work another person must do to keep that self-image functioning. The reversal between apparently free adults and the responsible daughter is the relationship underneath the excess.

Saffy's apparent reasonableness is funniest when it has a temperament of its own, rather than functioning as the author's permanent correction. Her mother's extravagance supplies a strong antagonist, but a good exchange needs more than one voice with a claim on the room. The practical household keeps the spectacle from becoming entirely self-sufficient.

Metacritic's critics computed
81/100

From 10 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
84/100

From 6 ratings.

24

Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 2015–2019

Comedy · 30 min episodes

B 76

The language moves quickly, but survival has left habits that speed cannot always solve. The strongest passages make optimism a difficult action rather than a permanent trait. Another joke can enlarge the character's life or hurry past something the premise needed time to hear.

A phrase Kimmy understands from an earlier part of her life can mean something different in the present. The joke then carries a gap produced by captivity, not merely a random eccentricity. The series is more humane when the other person has to respond to that gap. Another verbal invention should not automatically release the scene from noticing it.

Metacritic's critics computed
80/100

From 63 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
76/100

From 8 ratings.

25

Archer 2009–2023

Action, Adventure, Animation · 22 min episodes

A 83

Professional danger has to compete with grudges, corrections and private history. The interrupted briefing is a miniature version of the whole method. Talent remains real, while the inability to conduct an ordinary useful exchange keeps making that talent expensive for everybody else.

The briefing requires information to move in one direction, while private history keeps sending it elsewhere. A correction can be timed beautifully and still prevent the team from hearing something necessary. That double value gives the ensemble its distinctive rhythm. The verbal performance becomes thinner when the interruption no longer changes what anybody can do.

Metacritic's critics computed
79/100

From 82 critic reviews.

MEANRANK computed
83/100

From 9 ratings.

Where this comes from: Metacritic: computing Metascores · Metacritic: user votes are separate from the Metascore

Use the score to locate the argument

The most useful next step is a review of the particular season you intend to watch. Ask what it praises: the density of jokes, an uncomfortable performance, the structure of a farce or a relationship's accumulated history. Those are different recommendations.

The Larry Sanders Show and The Thick of It both examine institutions, but the pressure of the room is different. PEN15 and Malcolm in the Middle both make growing up uncomfortable without using the same distance from the child's experience.

A high score cannot choose among those methods. A low review count also need not make a programme unworthy; it makes the numerical claim less conclusive.

The list's value is the route it offers into specific work, with the source and limits still attached. It should not become a claim that one partial television record has settled the quality of an entire run.

For a different population and scale, see Metacritic's stored user scores. The comparison becomes informative when the difference is retained, rather than erased by multiplying a number.

← All lists