Most Contested TV Shows

The Series the rating platforms disagree about most. Not the ones that scored badly — the ones where critics, audiences and different countries arrived at genuinely different answers. Disagreement is measured against what each platform normally gives, so a low Criticker score and a high Google one only count as a split when they really are one.

100 results
1 Velma 23/100 · 129K votes · 2023–2024 · 7 ratings F 23 2 Masters of the Universe: Revelation 59/100 · 36K votes · 2021 · 5 ratings D 59 3 Day Break 68/100 · 8.9K votes · 2006–2008 · 5 ratings C 68 4 Star Trek: Starfleet Academy 55/100 · 37.6K votes · 2026 · 6 ratings D 55 5 The Acolyte 46/100 · 357.5K votes · 2024 · 9 ratings F 46 6 Ginny & Georgia 62/100 · 137.5K votes · 2021 · 8 ratings C 62 7 The Boys 74/100 · 1.7M votes · 2019–2026 · 9 ratings B 74 8 Batwoman 44/100 · 122K votes · 2019–2022 · 8 ratings F 44 9 The Idol 32/100 · 134.5K votes · 2023 · 8 ratings F 32 10 Resident Evil 34/100 · 54K votes · 2022 · 6 ratings F 34 11 Journeyman 64/100 · 10K votes · 2007 · 6 ratings C 64 12 Doctor Who 73/100 · 1.6M votes · 2005–2021 · 9 ratings B 73 13 Dear White People 63/100 · 30.5K votes · 2017–2021 · 5 ratings C 63 14 Stalker 56/100 · 18.8K votes · 2014–2015 · 6 ratings D 56 15 Kroll Show 68/100 · 5.7K votes · 2013–2015 · 6 ratings C 68 16 Life 71/100 · 37.3K votes · 2007–2009 · 7 ratings B 71 17 The L Word: Generation Q 64/100 · 9.4K votes · 2019–2023 · 5 ratings C 64 18 Saturday Night Live 66/100 · 242.4K votes · 1975 · 6 ratings C 66 19 Flaked 56/100 · 14K votes · 2016–2017 · 6 ratings D 56 20 Moonlight 56/100 · 26.1K votes · 2007–2008 · 6 ratings D 56 21 Willow 57/100 · 41.2K votes · 2022–2023 · 7 ratings D 57 22 The Black Donnellys 68/100 · 14.9K votes · 2007 · 5 ratings C 68 23 The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power 60/100 · 545.4K votes · 2022 · 9 ratings C 60 24 The Fairly OddParents 65/100 · 83.2K votes · 2001–2017 · 6 ratings C 65 25 Star Trek: Discovery 61/100 · 412.7K votes · 2017–2024 · 9 ratings C 61 26 Vikings: Valhalla 68/100 · 111.3K votes · 2022–2024 · 8 ratings C 68 27 Malcolm in the Middle: Life's Still Unfair 64/100 · 19.8K votes · 2026 · 5 ratings C 64 28 Surface 54/100 · 10.8K votes · 2005–2006 · 6 ratings D 54 29 Star Trek: The Next Generation 81/100 · 846.3K votes · 1987–1994 · 9 ratings A 81 30 The Twilight Zone 86/100 · 627.6K votes · 1959–1964 · 7 ratings A 86 31 Bleach 76/100 · 344.8K votes · 2004 · 5 ratings B 76 32 Naruto 78/100 · 398.6K votes · 2002–2007 · 6 ratings B 78 33 Quantum Leap 57/100 · 15.3K votes · 2022–2024 · 5 ratings D 57 34 Tomb Raider: The Legend of Lara Croft 54/100 · 10.1K votes · 2024–2025 · 5 ratings D 54 35 The Simpsons 80/100 · 2.2M votes · 1989 · 8 ratings A 80 36 National Treasure: Edge of History 43/100 · 15.3K votes · 2022–2023 · 5 ratings F 43 37 Stargate SG-1 77/100 · 396.7K votes · 1997–2007 · 7 ratings B 77 38 Naruto: Shippuden 82/100 · 654.3K votes · 2007–2017 · 7 ratings A 82 39 Insatiable 50/100 · 39.8K votes · 2018–2019 · 7 ratings D 50 40 1923 72/100 · 150.3K votes · 2022–2025 · 8 ratings B 72 41 Disjointed 58/100 · 13.2K votes · 2017–2018 · 6 ratings D 58 42 Castlevania: Nocturne 73/100 · 27.7K votes · 2023–2025 · 5 ratings B 73 43 Dexter's Laboratory 74/100 · 71.7K votes · 1996–2003 · 6 ratings B 74 44 The War at Home 53/100 · 9.6K votes · 2005–2007 · 5 ratings D 53 45 The Nevers 62/100 · 30.8K votes · 2021 · 6 ratings C 62 46 Black Lightning 67/100 · 32.4K votes · 2018–2021 · 5 ratings C 67 47 Ricky Gervais Alley Cats 46/100 · 9.1K votes · 2026 · 5 ratings F 46 48 Brotherhood 70/100 · 8.8K votes · 2006–2008 · 5 ratings B 70 49 Damien 56/100 · 9K votes · 2016 · 6 ratings D 56 50 SpongeBob SquarePants 74/100 · 392K votes · 1999 · 6 ratings B 74 51 New Amsterdam 62/100 · 118.1K votes · 2018–2023 · 7 ratings C 62 52 Rosewood 52/100 · 10.4K votes · 2015–2017 · 6 ratings D 52 53 Dragon Ball 79/100 · 152.7K votes · 1986–1989 · 5 ratings B 79 54 The Terminal List 68/100 · 163K votes · 2022 · 8 ratings C 68 55 Off the Map 59/100 · 5.5K votes · 2011 · 6 ratings D 59 56 Star Trek: Picard 67/100 · 260.1K votes · 2020–2023 · 8 ratings C 67 57 The Curse 72/100 · 76.3K votes · 2023–2024 · 6 ratings B 72 58 CSI: NY 63/100 · 117.6K votes · 2004–2013 · 7 ratings C 63 59 The Twilight Zone 53/100 · 21.7K votes · 2019–2020 · 5 ratings D 53 60 The Irregulars 59/100 · 19.4K votes · 2021 · 5 ratings D 59 61 X-Men 78/100 · 131.4K votes · 1992–1997 · 5 ratings B 78 62 The Last of Us 75/100 · 1.9M votes · 2023 · 9 ratings B 75 63 The Powerpuff Girls 71/100 · 69.8K votes · 1998–2005 · 6 ratings B 71 64 Rules of Engagement 63/100 · 38.5K votes · 2007–2013 · 6 ratings C 63 65 Imperfect Women 48/100 · 9K votes · 2026 · 5 ratings F 48 66 Full House 61/100 · 127.4K votes · 1987–1995 · 7 ratings C 61 67 Around the World in 80 Days 65/100 · 13.9K votes · 2021 · 5 ratings C 65 68 Eyes of Wakanda 63/100 · 32.8K votes · 2025 · 6 ratings C 63 69 The Spanish Princess 62/100 · 12.9K votes · 2019–2020 · 5 ratings C 62 70 Blue Mountain State 72/100 · 83.9K votes · 2010–2011 · 7 ratings B 72 71 We Are Lady Parts 79/100 · 8.4K votes · 2021–2024 · 6 ratings B 79 72 The Larry Sanders Show 81/100 · 10.7K votes · 1992–1998 · 6 ratings A 81 73 Gypsy 63/100 · 20.9K votes · 2017 · 6 ratings C 63 74 True Detective 77/100 · 1.3M votes · 2014 · 9 ratings B 77 75 Star Trek 78/100 · 441.7K votes · 1966–1969 · 7 ratings B 78 76 Clarice 54/100 · 13K votes · 2021 · 6 ratings D 54 77 Monty Python's Flying Circus 83/100 · 134.5K votes · 1969–1974 · 5 ratings A 83 78 She's Gotta Have It 66/100 · 5.6K votes · 2017–2019 · 6 ratings C 66 79 The Orville 73/100 · 263.3K votes · 2017–2022 · 8 ratings B 73 80 Star Trek: Lower Decks 73/100 · 32.6K votes · 2020–2024 · 6 ratings B 73 81 Ghost Whisperer 61/100 · 87K votes · 2005–2010 · 7 ratings C 61 82 Batman: The Animated Series 87/100 · 339.6K votes · 1992–1995 · 6 ratings A 87 83 The Tattooist of Auschwitz 70/100 · 14.6K votes · 2024 · 6 ratings B 70 84 Ransom 61/100 · 4.8K votes · 2017–2019 · 5 ratings C 61 85 Family Guy 69/100 · 1.1M votes · 1999 · 8 ratings C 69 86 Ballard 77/100 · 26.2K votes · 2025 · 5 ratings B 77 87 Invasion 70/100 · 13.9K votes · 2005–2006 · 5 ratings B 70 88 Flashpoint 76/100 · 19.8K votes · 2008–2012 · 5 ratings B 76 89 For The People 69/100 · 7.1K votes · 2018–2019 · 5 ratings C 69 90 First Kill 68/100 · 32.6K votes · 2022 · 6 ratings C 68 91 Hand of God 62/100 · 13.3K votes · 2014–2017 · 6 ratings C 62 92 Mixology 64/100 · 6.1K votes · 2013–2014 · 6 ratings C 64 93 Hustle 76/100 · 24.8K votes · 2004–2012 · 5 ratings B 76 94 Y: The Last Man 61/100 · 17.1K votes · 2021 · 5 ratings C 61 95 Maniac 72/100 · 196.1K votes · 2018 · 9 ratings B 72 96 Lanterns 73/100 · 76.4K votes · 2026 · 5 ratings B 73 97 Life & Beth 68/100 · 10.8K votes · 2022–2024 · 6 ratings C 68 98 Batman: Caped Crusader 72/100 · 20.5K votes · 2024 · 5 ratings B 72 99 Friends from College 58/100 · 26.3K votes · 2017–2019 · 6 ratings D 58 100 Pure Genius 60/100 · 5.1K votes · 2016–2017 · 6 ratings C 60