Movies Audiences Loved and Critics Didn't
Films the public rates far above the reviewers. The gap is the difference in points between what critics gave and what everybody else gave, on the same 0-100 scale.
1
The Green Room
D
59
2
Life Itself
C
62
3
The Vanishing of Sidney Hall
D
58
4
Modigliani
D
56
5
Four Rooms
C
62
6
The Number 23
D
56
7
Overcomer
C
63
8
Kung Pow: Enter the Fist
D
56
9
Citizen Vigilante
D
54
10
A Little Bit of Heaven
D
51
11
Twice Born
C
60
12
Mobsters
D
51
13
The Life of David Gale
C
67
14
Killing Me Softly
F
42
15
Out Cold
D
53
16
Diary of a Mad Black Woman
D
55
17
Run Hide Fight
C
61
18
The Tiger and the Snow
D
58
19
Major League II
F
46
20
Dutch
D
58
21
Cocktail
D
52
22
Dragonfly
D
54
23
All the King's Men
D
52
24
Grind
D
53
25
Drop Dead Fred
D
52
26
Pokémon: The First Movie
C
65
27
Collateral Beauty
D
57
28
A Thousand Words
D
50
29
With Honors
C
62
30
Joe Dirt
D
53
31
Dracula: Dead and Loving It
D
52
32
House of D
D
55
33
Supercross
F
42
34
Patch Adams
C
63
35
Peppermint
D
58
36
Beyond a Reasonable Doubt
F
45
37
Sweet November
D
59
38
2 Hearts
D
58
39
My Way
B
70
40
Redeeming Love
D
59
41
Half Baked
D
59
42
Gone Fishin'
F
42
43
Mr. Church
C
66
44
The Butterfly Effect
B
70
45
I Am Sam
C
69
46
A Family Man
D
54
47
Dhurandhar
B
71
48
The Best of Me
D
57
49
Down to You
F
38
50
A Cinderella Story
D
55
51
John Q
C
65
52
Grandma's Boy
C
60
53
Dhurandhar: The Revenge
B
71
54
Dead Man on Campus
D
52
55
Money Talks
D
58
56
The Pagemaster
D
58
57
Seven Pounds
C
67
58
A Night at the Roxbury
D
54
59
Eye for an Eye
F
47
60
Pokémon the Movie 2000
D
58
61
The Wash
F
44
62
The Starling
C
60
63
CBGB
D
52
64
The Death & Life of John F. Donovan
D
57
65
Little Boy
C
64
66
Dirty Work
D
57
67
The Scarlet Letter
F
49
68
The Choice
D
53
69
Gods and Generals
D
51
70
Law Abiding Citizen
C
66
71
8MM
D
58
72
Uptown Girls
D
59
73
Problem Child 2
F
44
74
Hansel & Gretel: Witch Hunters
D
55
75
Revolver
D
54
76
Safe Haven
D
59
77
Slackers
F
42
78
Beyond Borders
D
55
79
The in Crowd
F
35
80
Reagan
D
51
81
Black Dog
D
50
82
Grown Ups
D
55
83
Nine Lives
F
46
84
Saw 3D
D
50
85
Replicas
F
46
86
Mannequin
D
54
87
Yours, Mine & Ours
D
56
88
American Outlaws
F
48
89
Day of the Falcon
D
51
90
Problem Child
F
49
91
Because I Said So
F
49
92
Van Wilder
D
55
93
The Cobbler
F
49
94
Freelance
D
51
95
Good Luck Chuck
F
46
96
Serving Sara
F
36
97
Polar
D
52
98
47 Ronin
D
55
99
To Save a Life
D
59
100
88 Minutes
F
44
The Green Room
D
59
2
Life Itself
C
62
3
The Vanishing of Sidney Hall
D
58
4
Modigliani
D
56
5
Four Rooms
C
62
6
The Number 23
D
56
7
Overcomer
C
63
8
Kung Pow: Enter the Fist
D
56
9
Citizen Vigilante
D
54
10
A Little Bit of Heaven
D
51
11
Twice Born
C
60
12
Mobsters
D
51
13
The Life of David Gale
C
67
14
Killing Me Softly
F
42
15
Out Cold
D
53
16
Diary of a Mad Black Woman
D
55
17
Run Hide Fight
C
61
18
The Tiger and the Snow
D
58
19
Major League II
F
46
20
Dutch
D
58
21
Cocktail
D
52
22
Dragonfly
D
54
23
All the King's Men
D
52
24
Grind
D
53
25
Drop Dead Fred
D
52
26
Pokémon: The First Movie
C
65
27
Collateral Beauty
D
57
28
A Thousand Words
D
50
29
With Honors
C
62
30
Joe Dirt
D
53
31
Dracula: Dead and Loving It
D
52
32
House of D
D
55
33
Supercross
F
42
34
Patch Adams
C
63
35
Peppermint
D
58
36
Beyond a Reasonable Doubt
F
45
37
Sweet November
D
59
38
2 Hearts
D
58
39
My Way
B
70
40
Redeeming Love
D
59
41
Half Baked
D
59
42
Gone Fishin'
F
42
43
Mr. Church
C
66
44
The Butterfly Effect
B
70
45
I Am Sam
C
69
46
A Family Man
D
54
47
Dhurandhar
B
71
48
The Best of Me
D
57
49
Down to You
F
38
50
A Cinderella Story
D
55
51
John Q
C
65
52
Grandma's Boy
C
60
53
Dhurandhar: The Revenge
B
71
54
Dead Man on Campus
D
52
55
Money Talks
D
58
56
The Pagemaster
D
58
57
Seven Pounds
C
67
58
A Night at the Roxbury
D
54
59
Eye for an Eye
F
47
60
Pokémon the Movie 2000
D
58
61
The Wash
F
44
62
The Starling
C
60
63
CBGB
D
52
64
The Death & Life of John F. Donovan
D
57
65
Little Boy
C
64
66
Dirty Work
D
57
67
The Scarlet Letter
F
49
68
The Choice
D
53
69
Gods and Generals
D
51
70
Law Abiding Citizen
C
66
71
8MM
D
58
72
Uptown Girls
D
59
73
Problem Child 2
F
44
74
Hansel & Gretel: Witch Hunters
D
55
75
Revolver
D
54
76
Safe Haven
D
59
77
Slackers
F
42
78
Beyond Borders
D
55
79
The in Crowd
F
35
80
Reagan
D
51
81
Black Dog
D
50
82
Grown Ups
D
55
83
Nine Lives
F
46
84
Saw 3D
D
50
85
Replicas
F
46
86
Mannequin
D
54
87
Yours, Mine & Ours
D
56
88
American Outlaws
F
48
89
Day of the Falcon
D
51
90
Problem Child
F
49
91
Because I Said So
F
49
92
Van Wilder
D
55
93
The Cobbler
F
49
94
Freelance
D
51
95
Good Luck Chuck
F
46
96
Serving Sara
F
36
97
Polar
D
52
98
47 Ronin
D
55
99
To Save a Life
D
59
100
88 Minutes
F
44