TV Shows Audiences Loved and Critics Didn't
Series the public rates far above the reviewers. The gap is the difference in points between what critics gave and what everybody else gave, on the same 0-100 scale.
1
Stalker
D
56
2
Damien
D
56
3
Insatiable
D
50
4
The Black Donnellys
C
68
5
The War at Home
D
53
6
Rosewood
D
52
7
Rules of Engagement
C
63
8
Disjointed
D
58
9
Moonlight
D
56
10
$#*! My Dad Says
F
38
11
Blue Mountain State
B
72
12
Off the Map
D
59
13
The Mysteries of Laura
D
56
14
Friends with Better Lives
D
54
15
Pure Genius
C
60
16
Hand of God
C
62
17
Ghost Whisperer
C
61
18
Surface
D
54
19
Men at Work
C
66
20
The Terminal List
C
68
21
Outsourced
C
63
22
Full House
C
61
23
Mixology
C
64
24
Friends from College
D
58
25
Roadies
C
64
26
Second Chance
C
61
27
Stargate SG-1
B
77
28
Conviction
D
53
29
The Neighbors
D
59
30
Flashpoint
B
76
31
Fuller House
C
61
32
Notorious
F
49
33
Backstrom
C
65
34
Secrets and Lies
C
63
35
Here and Now
D
56
36
Lucky Louie
C
67
37
The Outpost
C
65
38
Gypsy
C
63
39
The Night Shift
C
69
40
Helstrom
D
54
41
The Life & Times of Tim
A
82
42
Motherland: Fort Salem
B
74
43
Criminal Minds
B
73
44
American Dad!
B
70
45
Emily Owens M.D.
C
60
46
Wolf Pack
C
60
47
The Brave
C
68
48
Selena: The Series
D
53
49
George Lopez
C
68
50
Ricky Gervais Alley Cats
F
46
51
Common Law
B
70
52
Gang Related
C
66
53
Private Practice
C
68
54
APB
D
59
55
On Call
C
67
56
Manhattan Love Story
D
53
57
Babylon 5
B
78
58
Emerald City
C
61
59
Anger Management
D
51
60
LA to Vegas
C
65
61
Tires
B
71
62
Star
C
63
63
ALF
C
66
64
Chicago Fire
B
72
65
Chicago P.D.
B
73
66
StartUp
B
73
67
Stargate: Atlantis
B
75
68
Messiah
C
66
69
Young & Hungry
C
68
70
Believe
C
64
71
Stitchers
C
68
72
Flaked
D
56
73
Boy Meets World
B
74
74
Inhumans
F
34
75
Queer as Folk
A
81
76
So Help Me Todd
B
71
77
Dexter: Original Sin
B
71
78
Bull
C
60
79
Baby Daddy
B
71
80
The Mick
C
69
81
Dynasty
B
72
82
Code Black
B
73
83
The Listener
C
62
84
A Million Little Things
B
71
85
Journeyman
C
64
86
The Ricky Gervais Show
A
81
87
The Royals
C
67
88
Harry's Law
C
67
89
The Last Tycoon
C
67
90
Salvation
C
62
91
First Kill
C
68
92
The Brink
C
69
93
Forever
B
72
94
Saving Hope
C
68
95
Tell Me a Story
C
64
96
Defying Gravity
C
65
97
NCIS
B
71
98
Girlboss
D
59
99
Undateable
B
70
100
Iron Fist
D
55
Stalker
D
56
2
Damien
D
56
3
Insatiable
D
50
4
The Black Donnellys
C
68
5
The War at Home
D
53
6
Rosewood
D
52
7
Rules of Engagement
C
63
8
Disjointed
D
58
9
Moonlight
D
56
10
$#*! My Dad Says
F
38
11
Blue Mountain State
B
72
12
Off the Map
D
59
13
The Mysteries of Laura
D
56
14
Friends with Better Lives
D
54
15
Pure Genius
C
60
16
Hand of God
C
62
17
Ghost Whisperer
C
61
18
Surface
D
54
19
Men at Work
C
66
20
The Terminal List
C
68
21
Outsourced
C
63
22
Full House
C
61
23
Mixology
C
64
24
Friends from College
D
58
25
Roadies
C
64
26
Second Chance
C
61
27
Stargate SG-1
B
77
28
Conviction
D
53
29
The Neighbors
D
59
30
Flashpoint
B
76
31
Fuller House
C
61
32
Notorious
F
49
33
Backstrom
C
65
34
Secrets and Lies
C
63
35
Here and Now
D
56
36
Lucky Louie
C
67
37
The Outpost
C
65
38
Gypsy
C
63
39
The Night Shift
C
69
40
Helstrom
D
54
41
The Life & Times of Tim
A
82
42
Motherland: Fort Salem
B
74
43
Criminal Minds
B
73
44
American Dad!
B
70
45
Emily Owens M.D.
C
60
46
Wolf Pack
C
60
47
The Brave
C
68
48
Selena: The Series
D
53
49
George Lopez
C
68
50
Ricky Gervais Alley Cats
F
46
51
Common Law
B
70
52
Gang Related
C
66
53
Private Practice
C
68
54
APB
D
59
55
On Call
C
67
56
Manhattan Love Story
D
53
57
Babylon 5
B
78
58
Emerald City
C
61
59
Anger Management
D
51
60
LA to Vegas
C
65
61
Tires
B
71
62
Star
C
63
63
ALF
C
66
64
Chicago Fire
B
72
65
Chicago P.D.
B
73
66
StartUp
B
73
67
Stargate: Atlantis
B
75
68
Messiah
C
66
69
Young & Hungry
C
68
70
Believe
C
64
71
Stitchers
C
68
72
Flaked
D
56
73
Boy Meets World
B
74
74
Inhumans
F
34
75
Queer as Folk
A
81
76
So Help Me Todd
B
71
77
Dexter: Original Sin
B
71
78
Bull
C
60
79
Baby Daddy
B
71
80
The Mick
C
69
81
Dynasty
B
72
82
Code Black
B
73
83
The Listener
C
62
84
A Million Little Things
B
71
85
Journeyman
C
64
86
The Ricky Gervais Show
A
81
87
The Royals
C
67
88
Harry's Law
C
67
89
The Last Tycoon
C
67
90
Salvation
C
62
91
First Kill
C
68
92
The Brink
C
69
93
Forever
B
72
94
Saving Hope
C
68
95
Tell Me a Story
C
64
96
Defying Gravity
C
65
97
NCIS
B
71
98
Girlboss
D
59
99
Undateable
B
70
100
Iron Fist
D
55