Highest Rated Mystery TV Shows
Every tv show below is scored by averaging its rating on every platform that carries it — IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Letterboxd, Google and more — into one number out of 100. Only titles rated by at least three platforms are ranked.
1
Gravity Falls
A+
90
2
The Apothecary Diaries
A+
90
3
Inside No. 9
A
89
4
Babylon Berlin
A
88
5
Alchemy of Souls
A
88
6
Moving
A
88
7
Signal
A
88
8
ERASED
A
88
9
Homicide: Life on the Street
A
88
10
Summer Time Rendering
A
88
11
Death Note
A
87
12
Wonderfalls
A
87
13
Batman: The Animated Series
A
87
14
Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated
A
87
15
Mouse
A
86
16
The Twilight Zone
A
86
17
Banana Fish
A
86
18
Dark
A
86
19
Mindhunter
A
86
20
Foyle's War
A
86
21
Widow's Bay
A
86
22
Sherlock
A
85
23
Moriarty the Patriot
A
85
24
Line of Duty
A
85
25
Steins;Gate
A
85
26
The Returned
A
85
27
Link Click
A
85
28
Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries
A
85
29
The Prisoner
A
85
30
The Americans
A
85
31
Happy Valley
A
85
32
Twin Peaks
A
85
33
Alfred Hitchcock Presents
A
85
34
Monster
A
84
35
Twin Peaks
A
84
36
Severance
A
84
37
The Midnight Gospel
A
84
38
Life on Mars
A
84
39
Baccano!
A
84
40
Serial Experiments Lain
A
84
41
The Bridge
A
84
42
Save Me
A
84
43
The Expanse
A
84
44
Mine
A
84
45
Murdoch Mysteries
A
84
46
The Pretender
A
84
47
Eerie, Indiana
A
84
48
Broadchurch
A
83
49
The Missing
A
83
50
Odd Taxi
A
83
51
White Collar
A
83
52
Kingdom
A
83
53
Mike Tyson Mysteries
A
83
54
Big Little Lies
A
83
55
Magnum, P.I.
A
83
56
A Shop for Killers
A
83
57
The Leftovers
A
83
58
Night Gallery
A
83
59
Utopia
A
83
60
Endeavour
A
83
61
Slow Horses
A
83
62
Damages
A
83
63
American Crime
A
83
64
The Summer Hikaru Died
A
83
65
The Good Wife
A
82
66
The Case Study of Vanitas
A
82
67
Fringe
A
82
68
Stranger Things
A
82
69
Persona
A
82
70
Ripper Street
A
82
71
The North Water
A
82
72
Bosch
A
82
73
Asur
A
82
74
The Glory
A
82
75
Lost
A
82
76
Ergo Proxy
A
82
77
Penny Dreadful
A
81
78
Star Trek: The Next Generation
A
81
79
Ethos
A
81
80
Vera
A
81
81
The Brokenwood Mysteries
A
81
82
Only Murders in the Building
A
81
83
Criminal Justice
A
81
84
The Deuce
A
81
85
Dead Boy Detectives
A
81
86
Homeland
A
81
87
Columbo
A
81
88
Trapped
A
81
89
Terror in Resonance
A
81
90
What's New, Scooby-Doo?
A
81
91
The Devil Judge
A
81
92
Black Mirror
A
80
93
The Uncanny Counter
A
80
94
Miss Scarlet
A
80
95
Happiness
A
80
96
Dexter
A
80
97
The Devil's Hour
A
80
98
Darker Than Black
A
80
99
Kolchak: The Night Stalker
A
80
100
Secrets of Sulphur Springs
A
80
Gravity Falls
A+
90
2
The Apothecary Diaries
A+
90
3
Inside No. 9
A
89
4
Babylon Berlin
A
88
5
Alchemy of Souls
A
88
6
Moving
A
88
7
Signal
A
88
8
ERASED
A
88
9
Homicide: Life on the Street
A
88
10
Summer Time Rendering
A
88
11
Death Note
A
87
12
Wonderfalls
A
87
13
Batman: The Animated Series
A
87
14
Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated
A
87
15
Mouse
A
86
16
The Twilight Zone
A
86
17
Banana Fish
A
86
18
Dark
A
86
19
Mindhunter
A
86
20
Foyle's War
A
86
21
Widow's Bay
A
86
22
Sherlock
A
85
23
Moriarty the Patriot
A
85
24
Line of Duty
A
85
25
Steins;Gate
A
85
26
The Returned
A
85
27
Link Click
A
85
28
Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries
A
85
29
The Prisoner
A
85
30
The Americans
A
85
31
Happy Valley
A
85
32
Twin Peaks
A
85
33
Alfred Hitchcock Presents
A
85
34
Monster
A
84
35
Twin Peaks
A
84
36
Severance
A
84
37
The Midnight Gospel
A
84
38
Life on Mars
A
84
39
Baccano!
A
84
40
Serial Experiments Lain
A
84
41
The Bridge
A
84
42
Save Me
A
84
43
The Expanse
A
84
44
Mine
A
84
45
Murdoch Mysteries
A
84
46
The Pretender
A
84
47
Eerie, Indiana
A
84
48
Broadchurch
A
83
49
The Missing
A
83
50
Odd Taxi
A
83
51
White Collar
A
83
52
Kingdom
A
83
53
Mike Tyson Mysteries
A
83
54
Big Little Lies
A
83
55
Magnum, P.I.
A
83
56
A Shop for Killers
A
83
57
The Leftovers
A
83
58
Night Gallery
A
83
59
Utopia
A
83
60
Endeavour
A
83
61
Slow Horses
A
83
62
Damages
A
83
63
American Crime
A
83
64
The Summer Hikaru Died
A
83
65
The Good Wife
A
82
66
The Case Study of Vanitas
A
82
67
Fringe
A
82
68
Stranger Things
A
82
69
Persona
A
82
70
Ripper Street
A
82
71
The North Water
A
82
72
Bosch
A
82
73
Asur
A
82
74
The Glory
A
82
75
Lost
A
82
76
Ergo Proxy
A
82
77
Penny Dreadful
A
81
78
Star Trek: The Next Generation
A
81
79
Ethos
A
81
80
Vera
A
81
81
The Brokenwood Mysteries
A
81
82
Only Murders in the Building
A
81
83
Criminal Justice
A
81
84
The Deuce
A
81
85
Dead Boy Detectives
A
81
86
Homeland
A
81
87
Columbo
A
81
88
Trapped
A
81
89
Terror in Resonance
A
81
90
What's New, Scooby-Doo?
A
81
91
The Devil Judge
A
81
92
Black Mirror
A
80
93
The Uncanny Counter
A
80
94
Miss Scarlet
A
80
95
Happiness
A
80
96
Dexter
A
80
97
The Devil's Hour
A
80
98
Darker Than Black
A
80
99
Kolchak: The Night Stalker
A
80
100
Secrets of Sulphur Springs
A
80