Highest Rated Mystery Movies
Every movie below is scored by averaging its rating on every platform that carries it — IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Letterboxd, Google and more — into one number out of 100. Only titles rated by at least three platforms are ranked.
1001
Freelancers
F
38
1002
Silent Hill: Revelation 3D
F
37
1003
The Dinner
F
37
1004
Prom Night
F
37
1005
My Soul to Take
F
37
1006
The Cold Light of Day
F
37
1007
Altitude
F
36
1008
The Mortuary Assistant
F
36
1009
One Missed Call
F
36
1010
Basic Instinct 2
F
36
1011
The in Crowd
F
35
1012
Black Christmas
F
35
1013
Wounds
F
35
1014
Midnight in the Switchgrass
F
34
1015
Escape Plan 2: Hades
F
34
1016
Urban Legends: Final Cut
F
34
1017
Exposed
F
33
1018
Psycho Killer
F
32
1019
S. Darko
F
32
1020
Return to Silent Hill
F
32
1021
Killers Anonymous
F
31
1022
Brazen
F
31
1023
Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2
F
30
1024
Soul Survivors
F
28
1025
Home Sweet Home: Rebirth
F
27
Freelancers
F
38
1002
Silent Hill: Revelation 3D
F
37
1003
The Dinner
F
37
1004
Prom Night
F
37
1005
My Soul to Take
F
37
1006
The Cold Light of Day
F
37
1007
Altitude
F
36
1008
The Mortuary Assistant
F
36
1009
One Missed Call
F
36
1010
Basic Instinct 2
F
36
1011
The in Crowd
F
35
1012
Black Christmas
F
35
1013
Wounds
F
35
1014
Midnight in the Switchgrass
F
34
1015
Escape Plan 2: Hades
F
34
1016
Urban Legends: Final Cut
F
34
1017
Exposed
F
33
1018
Psycho Killer
F
32
1019
S. Darko
F
32
1020
Return to Silent Hill
F
32
1021
Killers Anonymous
F
31
1022
Brazen
F
31
1023
Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2
F
30
1024
Soul Survivors
F
28
1025
Home Sweet Home: Rebirth
F
27