Highest Rated Mystery Movies
Every movie below is scored by averaging its rating on every platform that carries it — IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Letterboxd, Google and more — into one number out of 100. Only titles rated by at least three platforms are ranked.
901
Deception
F
47
902
G20
F
47
903
Shelby Oaks
F
47
904
The Final Destination
F
47
905
Bad Santa 2
F
46
906
Down a Dark Hall
F
46
907
Righteous Kill
F
46
908
All I See Is You
F
46
909
Once Upon a Time in Venice
F
46
910
Allegiant
F
46
911
Cube Zero
F
46
912
Meeting Evil
F
46
913
House of Spoils
F
46
914
Sherlock Gnomes
F
46
915
Scream 7
F
46
916
Nine Dead
F
46
917
The Whole Truth
F
46
918
Striking Distance
F
46
919
24 Hours with Gaspar
F
46
920
The Final Conflict
F
46
921
Kill Me Three Times
F
46
922
Mute
F
46
923
Paranormal Activity: Next of Kin
F
45
924
Keeper
F
45
925
Deep
F
45
926
Survivor
F
45
927
Atlas Shrugged: Part I
F
45
928
Kidnapping Mr. Heineken
F
45
929
I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House
F
45
930
Strangerland
F
45
931
Umma
F
45
932
The Unholy
F
45
933
Voice from the Stone
F
45
934
The Do-Over
F
45
935
Polaroid
F
45
936
Terminal
F
45
937
Abduction
F
45
938
The Woman in the Yard
F
45
939
The Oxford Murders
F
44
940
The Haunted Mansion
F
44
941
The Deep House
F
44
942
Horsemen
F
44
943
I Still Know What You Did Last Summer
F
44
944
Visions
F
44
945
Whiteout
F
44
946
88 Minutes
F
44
947
Regression
F
44
948
Vanishing on 7th Street
F
44
949
Holidays
F
44
950
The Resident
F
44
951
Jade
F
44
952
Blackway
F
43
953
And Soon the Darkness
F
43
954
Intrusion
F
43
955
Wander
F
43
956
Sorority Row
F
43
957
Swimfan
F
43
958
Almost Cops
F
43
959
Last Man Down
F
43
960
10x10
F
43
961
Reeker
F
43
962
The Truth About Charlie
F
43
963
Night Patrol
F
43
964
Alex Cross
F
43
965
HIM
F
43
966
The Woman in Cabin 10
F
42
967
Color of Night
F
42
968
The Messengers
F
42
969
Twixt
F
42
970
Flight 7500
F
42
971
Imaginary
F
42
972
Hangman
F
42
973
November Criminals
F
42
974
Fantasy Island
F
41
975
Awoken
F
41
976
Twisted
F
41
977
The Snowman
F
41
978
Freedomland
F
41
979
An American Haunting
F
41
980
8 Heads in a Duffel Bag
F
41
981
Black Christmas
F
41
982
Picking Up the Pieces
F
40
983
The Unborn
F
40
984
Abandon
F
40
985
Pay the Ghost
F
40
986
The Grudge 3
F
40
987
Area 51
F
40
988
There's Someone Inside Your House
F
40
989
Eye of the Beholder
F
39
990
Brahms: The Boy II
F
39
991
Housefull 5
F
39
992
Cold Creek Manor
F
39
993
They/Them
F
39
994
Boogeyman
F
39
995
Holland
F
39
996
Dylan Dog: Dead of Night
F
39
997
The Forest
F
39
998
400 Days
F
39
999
How It Ends
F
38
1000
Fear Street: Prom Queen
F
38
Deception
F
47
902
G20
F
47
903
Shelby Oaks
F
47
904
The Final Destination
F
47
905
Bad Santa 2
F
46
906
Down a Dark Hall
F
46
907
Righteous Kill
F
46
908
All I See Is You
F
46
909
Once Upon a Time in Venice
F
46
910
Allegiant
F
46
911
Cube Zero
F
46
912
Meeting Evil
F
46
913
House of Spoils
F
46
914
Sherlock Gnomes
F
46
915
Scream 7
F
46
916
Nine Dead
F
46
917
The Whole Truth
F
46
918
Striking Distance
F
46
919
24 Hours with Gaspar
F
46
920
The Final Conflict
F
46
921
Kill Me Three Times
F
46
922
Mute
F
46
923
Paranormal Activity: Next of Kin
F
45
924
Keeper
F
45
925
Deep
F
45
926
Survivor
F
45
927
Atlas Shrugged: Part I
F
45
928
Kidnapping Mr. Heineken
F
45
929
I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House
F
45
930
Strangerland
F
45
931
Umma
F
45
932
The Unholy
F
45
933
Voice from the Stone
F
45
934
The Do-Over
F
45
935
Polaroid
F
45
936
Terminal
F
45
937
Abduction
F
45
938
The Woman in the Yard
F
45
939
The Oxford Murders
F
44
940
The Haunted Mansion
F
44
941
The Deep House
F
44
942
Horsemen
F
44
943
I Still Know What You Did Last Summer
F
44
944
Visions
F
44
945
Whiteout
F
44
946
88 Minutes
F
44
947
Regression
F
44
948
Vanishing on 7th Street
F
44
949
Holidays
F
44
950
The Resident
F
44
951
Jade
F
44
952
Blackway
F
43
953
And Soon the Darkness
F
43
954
Intrusion
F
43
955
Wander
F
43
956
Sorority Row
F
43
957
Swimfan
F
43
958
Almost Cops
F
43
959
Last Man Down
F
43
960
10x10
F
43
961
Reeker
F
43
962
The Truth About Charlie
F
43
963
Night Patrol
F
43
964
Alex Cross
F
43
965
HIM
F
43
966
The Woman in Cabin 10
F
42
967
Color of Night
F
42
968
The Messengers
F
42
969
Twixt
F
42
970
Flight 7500
F
42
971
Imaginary
F
42
972
Hangman
F
42
973
November Criminals
F
42
974
Fantasy Island
F
41
975
Awoken
F
41
976
Twisted
F
41
977
The Snowman
F
41
978
Freedomland
F
41
979
An American Haunting
F
41
980
8 Heads in a Duffel Bag
F
41
981
Black Christmas
F
41
982
Picking Up the Pieces
F
40
983
The Unborn
F
40
984
Abandon
F
40
985
Pay the Ghost
F
40
986
The Grudge 3
F
40
987
Area 51
F
40
988
There's Someone Inside Your House
F
40
989
Eye of the Beholder
F
39
990
Brahms: The Boy II
F
39
991
Housefull 5
F
39
992
Cold Creek Manor
F
39
993
They/Them
F
39
994
Boogeyman
F
39
995
Holland
F
39
996
Dylan Dog: Dead of Night
F
39
997
The Forest
F
39
998
400 Days
F
39
999
How It Ends
F
38
1000
Fear Street: Prom Queen
F
38