Highest Rated Mystery Movies
Every movie below is scored by averaging its rating on every platform that carries it — IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Letterboxd, Google and more — into one number out of 100. Only titles rated by at least three platforms are ranked.
801
Scooby-Doo
D
52
802
Wer
D
52
803
Scooby-Doo! The Mystery Begins
D
52
804
Gretel & Hansel
D
51
805
The X Files: I Want to Believe
D
51
806
The Adventures of Ford Fairlane
D
51
807
Urban Legend
D
51
808
The Invasion
D
51
809
Dream House
D
51
810
The Night Listener
D
51
811
Borderless Fog
D
51
812
Dark Places
D
51
813
Haunter
D
51
814
Cleaner
D
51
815
Brake
D
51
816
The Relic
D
51
817
Hold the Dark
D
51
818
Flypaper
D
51
819
24 Hours to Live
D
51
820
7 Women and a Murder
D
51
821
The Woman in the Window
D
51
822
In the Cut
D
51
823
Open Grave
D
51
824
After.Life
D
51
825
Dobaaraa
D
51
826
A Fall from Grace
D
51
827
Murder at 1600
D
50
828
The Woods
D
50
829
Murder Mystery 2
D
50
830
The Fourth Kind
D
50
831
Scooby-Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed
D
50
832
Dark Nuns
D
50
833
Opus
D
50
834
Hypnotic
D
50
835
Whistle
D
50
836
Sphere
D
50
837
Manhattan Night
D
50
838
The Weekend Away
D
50
839
Gone
D
50
840
Hubie Halloween
D
50
841
Fragile
D
50
842
The Factory
D
50
843
Come and Find Me
D
50
844
Rememory
D
50
845
The Forgotten
D
50
846
Perfect Stranger
D
50
847
The Paperboy
D
50
848
Disturbing Behavior
D
50
849
Spiral: From the Book of Saw
D
50
850
Premonition
D
50
851
Dude, Where's My Car?
D
50
852
Winter's Tale
D
50
853
Silent House
F
49
854
The Clearing
F
49
855
Halloween III: Season of the Witch
F
49
856
Beckett
F
49
857
The Good German
F
49
858
All the Boys Love Mandy Lane
F
49
859
6 Souls
F
49
860
Red Riding Hood
F
49
861
Deep Water
F
49
862
Death Warrant
F
49
863
The Watchers
F
49
864
Cut Bank
F
49
865
Armored
F
48
866
Columbus Circle
F
48
867
Ghost Ship
F
48
868
Devil's Pass
F
48
869
Stone
F
48
870
Scooby-Doo! Curse of the Lake Monster
F
48
871
Lady in the Water
F
48
872
Another Simple Favor
F
48
873
Passion
F
48
874
Wrecked
F
48
875
A Classic Horror Story
F
48
876
Mission to Mars
F
48
877
Fountain of Youth
F
48
878
The Owners
F
48
879
Hell
F
48
880
Kung Fu Yoga
F
48
881
Shanghai
F
48
882
The Haunting
F
48
883
The Lie
F
48
884
The Home
F
48
885
Club Dread
F
48
886
Quarantine 2: Terminal
F
48
887
Evidence
F
48
888
Truth or Die
F
48
889
In Dreams
F
47
890
Cube²: Hypercube
F
47
891
Inheritance
F
47
892
Synchronicity
F
47
893
Domestic Disturbance
F
47
894
Suburbicon
F
47
895
No One Gets Out Alive
F
47
896
The Dark
F
47
897
Drowning Mona
F
47
898
I Know What You Did Last Summer
F
47
899
The Pink Panther 2
F
47
900
The Cloverfield Paradox
F
47
Scooby-Doo
D
52
802
Wer
D
52
803
Scooby-Doo! The Mystery Begins
D
52
804
Gretel & Hansel
D
51
805
The X Files: I Want to Believe
D
51
806
The Adventures of Ford Fairlane
D
51
807
Urban Legend
D
51
808
The Invasion
D
51
809
Dream House
D
51
810
The Night Listener
D
51
811
Borderless Fog
D
51
812
Dark Places
D
51
813
Haunter
D
51
814
Cleaner
D
51
815
Brake
D
51
816
The Relic
D
51
817
Hold the Dark
D
51
818
Flypaper
D
51
819
24 Hours to Live
D
51
820
7 Women and a Murder
D
51
821
The Woman in the Window
D
51
822
In the Cut
D
51
823
Open Grave
D
51
824
After.Life
D
51
825
Dobaaraa
D
51
826
A Fall from Grace
D
51
827
Murder at 1600
D
50
828
The Woods
D
50
829
Murder Mystery 2
D
50
830
The Fourth Kind
D
50
831
Scooby-Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed
D
50
832
Dark Nuns
D
50
833
Opus
D
50
834
Hypnotic
D
50
835
Whistle
D
50
836
Sphere
D
50
837
Manhattan Night
D
50
838
The Weekend Away
D
50
839
Gone
D
50
840
Hubie Halloween
D
50
841
Fragile
D
50
842
The Factory
D
50
843
Come and Find Me
D
50
844
Rememory
D
50
845
The Forgotten
D
50
846
Perfect Stranger
D
50
847
The Paperboy
D
50
848
Disturbing Behavior
D
50
849
Spiral: From the Book of Saw
D
50
850
Premonition
D
50
851
Dude, Where's My Car?
D
50
852
Winter's Tale
D
50
853
Silent House
F
49
854
The Clearing
F
49
855
Halloween III: Season of the Witch
F
49
856
Beckett
F
49
857
The Good German
F
49
858
All the Boys Love Mandy Lane
F
49
859
6 Souls
F
49
860
Red Riding Hood
F
49
861
Deep Water
F
49
862
Death Warrant
F
49
863
The Watchers
F
49
864
Cut Bank
F
49
865
Armored
F
48
866
Columbus Circle
F
48
867
Ghost Ship
F
48
868
Devil's Pass
F
48
869
Stone
F
48
870
Scooby-Doo! Curse of the Lake Monster
F
48
871
Lady in the Water
F
48
872
Another Simple Favor
F
48
873
Passion
F
48
874
Wrecked
F
48
875
A Classic Horror Story
F
48
876
Mission to Mars
F
48
877
Fountain of Youth
F
48
878
The Owners
F
48
879
Hell
F
48
880
Kung Fu Yoga
F
48
881
Shanghai
F
48
882
The Haunting
F
48
883
The Lie
F
48
884
The Home
F
48
885
Club Dread
F
48
886
Quarantine 2: Terminal
F
48
887
Evidence
F
48
888
Truth or Die
F
48
889
In Dreams
F
47
890
Cube²: Hypercube
F
47
891
Inheritance
F
47
892
Synchronicity
F
47
893
Domestic Disturbance
F
47
894
Suburbicon
F
47
895
No One Gets Out Alive
F
47
896
The Dark
F
47
897
Drowning Mona
F
47
898
I Know What You Did Last Summer
F
47
899
The Pink Panther 2
F
47
900
The Cloverfield Paradox
F
47