Highest Rated Mystery TV Shows
Every tv show below is scored by averaging its rating on every platform that carries it — IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Letterboxd, Google and more — into one number out of 100. Only titles rated by at least three platforms are ranked.
301
The Chestnut Man
B
72
302
Blue Exorcist
B
72
303
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
B
72
304
Bones
B
72
305
Yellowjackets
B
72
306
Annika
B
72
307
Blue Bloods
B
72
308
Forever
B
72
309
The Resort
B
72
310
The Hollow
B
72
311
Maniac
B
72
312
The Woman in the Wall
B
72
313
Rizzoli & Isles
B
72
314
Homecoming
B
72
315
John Doe
B
72
316
Tower of God
B
72
317
The Promised Neverland
B
72
318
Wrecked
B
72
319
Shardlake
B
72
320
The Snow Girl
B
72
321
Archive 81
B
72
322
Flashforward
B
72
323
The Dresden Files
B
72
324
Twisted
B
72
325
All Her Fault
B
72
326
Batman: Caped Crusader
B
72
327
Katla
B
72
328
30 Coins
B
72
329
Tales of the City
B
72
330
Murder in the First
B
72
331
Dollhouse
B
71
332
Revenge
B
71
333
Presumed Innocent
B
71
334
Dark Angel
B
71
335
Tell Me Your Secrets
B
71
336
The Chelsea Detective
B
71
337
Temple
B
71
338
Upload
B
71
339
So Help Me Todd
B
71
340
American Horror Story
B
71
341
Dexter: Original Sin
B
71
342
Them
B
71
343
Tell Me Lies
B
71
344
Life
B
71
345
Gyeongseong Creature
B
71
346
3 Body Problem
B
71
347
The 4400
B
71
348
Jericho
B
71
349
The Bondsman
B
71
350
Legends
B
71
351
CSI: Vegas
B
71
352
50M²
B
71
353
Motive
B
71
354
The Peripheral
B
70
355
Salem
B
70
356
Sherlock & Daughter
B
70
357
Yeh Kaali Kaali Ankhein
B
70
358
Dispatches from Elsewhere
B
70
359
The Night Agent
B
70
360
The Strain
B
70
361
Charmed
B
70
362
American Gods
B
70
363
The Alienist
B
70
364
The Flight Attendant
B
70
365
The 8 Show
B
70
366
Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
B
70
367
Three Pines
B
70
368
1899
B
70
369
Truth Be Told
B
70
370
Invasion
B
70
371
Guillermo del Toro's Cabinet of Curiosities
C
69
372
The Society
C
69
373
Elfen Lied
C
69
374
Biohackers
C
69
375
Eye Candy
C
69
376
Black Doves
C
69
377
Hellbound
C
69
378
Haven
C
69
379
The Silent Sea
C
69
380
Body of Proof
C
69
381
The Mess You Leave Behind
C
69
382
Sunny
C
69
383
Outer Range
C
69
384
Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen
C
69
385
Sisyphus: The Myth
C
69
386
I Am the Night
C
69
387
The Gates
C
69
388
Hidden
C
69
389
Outer Banks
C
68
390
The Hunting Wives
C
68
391
Stitchers
C
68
392
Long Bright River
C
68
393
Sleepy Hollow
C
68
394
Lovecraft Country
C
68
395
The Lying Game
C
68
396
Down Cemetery Road
C
68
397
The Chalet
C
68
398
First Kill
C
68
399
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
C
68
400
Helix
C
68
The Chestnut Man
B
72
302
Blue Exorcist
B
72
303
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
B
72
304
Bones
B
72
305
Yellowjackets
B
72
306
Annika
B
72
307
Blue Bloods
B
72
308
Forever
B
72
309
The Resort
B
72
310
The Hollow
B
72
311
Maniac
B
72
312
The Woman in the Wall
B
72
313
Rizzoli & Isles
B
72
314
Homecoming
B
72
315
John Doe
B
72
316
Tower of God
B
72
317
The Promised Neverland
B
72
318
Wrecked
B
72
319
Shardlake
B
72
320
The Snow Girl
B
72
321
Archive 81
B
72
322
Flashforward
B
72
323
The Dresden Files
B
72
324
Twisted
B
72
325
All Her Fault
B
72
326
Batman: Caped Crusader
B
72
327
Katla
B
72
328
30 Coins
B
72
329
Tales of the City
B
72
330
Murder in the First
B
72
331
Dollhouse
B
71
332
Revenge
B
71
333
Presumed Innocent
B
71
334
Dark Angel
B
71
335
Tell Me Your Secrets
B
71
336
The Chelsea Detective
B
71
337
Temple
B
71
338
Upload
B
71
339
So Help Me Todd
B
71
340
American Horror Story
B
71
341
Dexter: Original Sin
B
71
342
Them
B
71
343
Tell Me Lies
B
71
344
Life
B
71
345
Gyeongseong Creature
B
71
346
3 Body Problem
B
71
347
The 4400
B
71
348
Jericho
B
71
349
The Bondsman
B
71
350
Legends
B
71
351
CSI: Vegas
B
71
352
50M²
B
71
353
Motive
B
71
354
The Peripheral
B
70
355
Salem
B
70
356
Sherlock & Daughter
B
70
357
Yeh Kaali Kaali Ankhein
B
70
358
Dispatches from Elsewhere
B
70
359
The Night Agent
B
70
360
The Strain
B
70
361
Charmed
B
70
362
American Gods
B
70
363
The Alienist
B
70
364
The Flight Attendant
B
70
365
The 8 Show
B
70
366
Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
B
70
367
Three Pines
B
70
368
1899
B
70
369
Truth Be Told
B
70
370
Invasion
B
70
371
Guillermo del Toro's Cabinet of Curiosities
C
69
372
The Society
C
69
373
Elfen Lied
C
69
374
Biohackers
C
69
375
Eye Candy
C
69
376
Black Doves
C
69
377
Hellbound
C
69
378
Haven
C
69
379
The Silent Sea
C
69
380
Body of Proof
C
69
381
The Mess You Leave Behind
C
69
382
Sunny
C
69
383
Outer Range
C
69
384
Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen
C
69
385
Sisyphus: The Myth
C
69
386
I Am the Night
C
69
387
The Gates
C
69
388
Hidden
C
69
389
Outer Banks
C
68
390
The Hunting Wives
C
68
391
Stitchers
C
68
392
Long Bright River
C
68
393
Sleepy Hollow
C
68
394
Lovecraft Country
C
68
395
The Lying Game
C
68
396
Down Cemetery Road
C
68
397
The Chalet
C
68
398
First Kill
C
68
399
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
C
68
400
Helix
C
68