Highest Rated Mystery TV Shows
Every tv show below is scored by averaging its rating on every platform that carries it — IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Letterboxd, Google and more — into one number out of 100. Only titles rated by at least three platforms are ranked.
401
God Friended Me
C
68
402
The Family
C
68
403
Scream Queens
C
68
404
Disclaimer
C
68
405
Absentia
C
68
406
Steal
C
67
407
The Power
C
67
408
The Marked Heart
C
67
409
Nancy Drew
C
67
410
Murderville
C
67
411
The Third Day
C
67
412
The Whispers
C
67
413
The Head
C
67
414
Bodkin
C
67
415
Lincoln Rhyme: Hunt for the Bone Collector
C
67
416
Before We Die
C
67
417
Elite
C
66
418
Ringer
C
66
419
Messiah
C
66
420
666 Park Avenue
C
66
421
Crisis
C
66
422
White Lines
C
66
423
After the Flood
C
66
424
Black Bullet
C
66
425
The Event
C
66
426
The Better Sister
C
66
427
Goosebumps
C
66
428
Mosaic
C
65
429
Numb3rs
C
65
430
Aashram
C
65
431
Crime
C
65
432
High-Rise Invasion
C
65
433
Designated Survivor
C
65
434
Defying Gravity
C
65
435
Wayward Pines
C
65
436
The Great Indian Murder
C
65
437
The Name of the Rose
C
64
438
The Suspect
C
64
439
Young Wallander
C
64
440
Constellation
C
64
441
Ragnarok
C
64
442
The Rook
C
64
443
Scream: The TV Series
C
64
444
Slasher
C
64
445
Manifest
C
63
446
Touch
C
63
447
Marcella
C
63
448
Locke & Key
C
63
449
American Gothic
C
63
450
Relic Hunter
C
63
451
The River
C
63
452
56 Days
C
63
453
Coroner
C
63
454
Two Summers
C
63
455
Ratched
C
63
456
Missing
C
63
457
Ravenswood
C
63
458
The Midnight Club
C
63
459
Riverdale
C
63
460
CSI: NY
C
63
461
HIS & HERS
C
63
462
Red Rose
C
63
463
The Messengers
C
62
464
Bloodride
C
62
465
Inside Man
C
62
466
Terra Nova
C
62
467
CSI: Miami
C
62
468
NCIS: Los Angeles
C
62
469
Hunters
C
62
470
Mortal Wound
C
62
471
Ridley
C
62
472
I Will Find You
C
61
473
Fear Itself
C
61
474
Death and Other Details
C
61
475
The Midwich Cuckoos
C
61
476
Ghost Whisperer
C
61
477
Red Eye
C
61
478
Liar
C
61
479
The Order
C
61
480
Big Sky
C
61
481
Shark
C
60
482
The Perfect Couple
C
60
483
Quantico
C
60
484
Money Heist: Korea - Joint Economic Area
C
60
485
Countdown
C
60
486
Persons Unknown
C
60
487
Rana Naidu
D
59
488
Z Nation
D
59
489
The Irregulars
D
59
490
Utopia
D
58
491
Dead of Summer
D
58
492
13 Reasons Why
D
58
493
Tandav
D
58
494
Agatha Christie's Seven Dials
D
57
495
Nine Perfect Strangers
D
57
496
When the Phone Rings
D
57
497
Under the Dome
D
57
498
Hemlock Grove
D
57
499
Alcatraz
D
57
500
Quantum Leap
D
57
God Friended Me
C
68
402
The Family
C
68
403
Scream Queens
C
68
404
Disclaimer
C
68
405
Absentia
C
68
406
Steal
C
67
407
The Power
C
67
408
The Marked Heart
C
67
409
Nancy Drew
C
67
410
Murderville
C
67
411
The Third Day
C
67
412
The Whispers
C
67
413
The Head
C
67
414
Bodkin
C
67
415
Lincoln Rhyme: Hunt for the Bone Collector
C
67
416
Before We Die
C
67
417
Elite
C
66
418
Ringer
C
66
419
Messiah
C
66
420
666 Park Avenue
C
66
421
Crisis
C
66
422
White Lines
C
66
423
After the Flood
C
66
424
Black Bullet
C
66
425
The Event
C
66
426
The Better Sister
C
66
427
Goosebumps
C
66
428
Mosaic
C
65
429
Numb3rs
C
65
430
Aashram
C
65
431
Crime
C
65
432
High-Rise Invasion
C
65
433
Designated Survivor
C
65
434
Defying Gravity
C
65
435
Wayward Pines
C
65
436
The Great Indian Murder
C
65
437
The Name of the Rose
C
64
438
The Suspect
C
64
439
Young Wallander
C
64
440
Constellation
C
64
441
Ragnarok
C
64
442
The Rook
C
64
443
Scream: The TV Series
C
64
444
Slasher
C
64
445
Manifest
C
63
446
Touch
C
63
447
Marcella
C
63
448
Locke & Key
C
63
449
American Gothic
C
63
450
Relic Hunter
C
63
451
The River
C
63
452
56 Days
C
63
453
Coroner
C
63
454
Two Summers
C
63
455
Ratched
C
63
456
Missing
C
63
457
Ravenswood
C
63
458
The Midnight Club
C
63
459
Riverdale
C
63
460
CSI: NY
C
63
461
HIS & HERS
C
63
462
Red Rose
C
63
463
The Messengers
C
62
464
Bloodride
C
62
465
Inside Man
C
62
466
Terra Nova
C
62
467
CSI: Miami
C
62
468
NCIS: Los Angeles
C
62
469
Hunters
C
62
470
Mortal Wound
C
62
471
Ridley
C
62
472
I Will Find You
C
61
473
Fear Itself
C
61
474
Death and Other Details
C
61
475
The Midwich Cuckoos
C
61
476
Ghost Whisperer
C
61
477
Red Eye
C
61
478
Liar
C
61
479
The Order
C
61
480
Big Sky
C
61
481
Shark
C
60
482
The Perfect Couple
C
60
483
Quantico
C
60
484
Money Heist: Korea - Joint Economic Area
C
60
485
Countdown
C
60
486
Persons Unknown
C
60
487
Rana Naidu
D
59
488
Z Nation
D
59
489
The Irregulars
D
59
490
Utopia
D
58
491
Dead of Summer
D
58
492
13 Reasons Why
D
58
493
Tandav
D
58
494
Agatha Christie's Seven Dials
D
57
495
Nine Perfect Strangers
D
57
496
When the Phone Rings
D
57
497
Under the Dome
D
57
498
Hemlock Grove
D
57
499
Alcatraz
D
57
500
Quantum Leap
D
57