Highest Rated Mystery Movies
Every movie below is scored by averaging its rating on every platform that carries it — IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Letterboxd, Google and more — into one number out of 100. Only titles rated by at least three platforms are ranked.
601
Session 9
D
59
602
Enter Nowhere
D
59
603
Grand Piano
D
59
604
Cam
D
59
605
Final Destination 5
D
59
606
Night Train to Lisbon
D
59
607
Jigsaw
D
59
608
Vidocq
D
59
609
Encounter
D
59
610
The Buckingham Murders
D
59
611
Society
D
59
612
It Comes at Night
D
59
613
Iron Lung
D
59
614
The Mothman Prophecies
D
59
615
The Losers
D
59
616
Lost Girls
D
59
617
The Arrival
D
59
618
Flightplan
D
58
619
Don't Worry Darling
D
58
620
Diabolik
D
58
621
The Vanishing of Sidney Hall
D
58
622
A Cure for Wellness
D
58
623
Brokedown Palace
D
58
624
undertone
D
58
625
Red Sparrow
D
58
626
Pandorum
D
58
627
Significant Other
D
58
628
RRRrrrr!!!
D
58
629
American Sweatshop
D
58
630
Below
D
58
631
Blindness
D
58
632
The Final Cut
D
58
633
Resurrection
D
58
634
The Legacy of the Bones
D
58
635
The International
D
58
636
We Are Still Here
D
58
637
Pinocchio: Unstrung
D
58
638
Kaboom
D
58
639
I Know What You Did Last Summer
D
58
640
The Bat
D
58
641
13 Ghosts
D
58
642
The Deep End of the Ocean
D
58
643
Snake Eyes
D
58
644
The Lodge
D
58
645
May the Devil Take You Too
D
58
646
Lifeforce
D
58
647
The Marsh King's Daughter
D
58
648
The Girl on the Train
D
58
649
Beyond the Black Rainbow
D
58
650
8MM
D
58
651
Sahara
D
58
652
The Blackcoat's Daughter
D
58
653
Along Came a Spider
D
58
654
The Net
D
57
655
Shimmer Lake
D
57
656
Jeepers Creepers
D
57
657
Rubber
D
57
658
Black Butterfly
D
57
659
The Empty Man
D
57
660
Arkansas
D
57
661
Sea Fever
D
57
662
Final Destination 3
D
57
663
Cold Prey
D
57
664
The Canal
D
57
665
Paranormal Activity 3
D
57
666
Escape Room: Tournament of Champions
D
57
667
The Den
D
57
668
Cuckoo
D
57
669
Nancy Drew
D
57
670
The Taking of Deborah Logan
D
57
671
Come Play
D
57
672
All the Old Knives
D
57
673
Knock at the Cabin
D
57
674
2:22
D
57
675
High Life
D
57
676
Bone Lake
D
57
677
The Midnight Meat Train
D
57
678
Mojin: The Lost Legend
D
57
679
Pride and Glory
D
57
680
The Raven
D
57
681
Lee Cronin's The Mummy
D
57
682
Message from the King
D
57
683
Who's the Man?
D
57
684
High Crimes
D
57
685
Backtrack
D
57
686
Descendent
D
56
687
A Widow's Game
D
56
688
The Book of Henry
D
56
689
Overdrive
D
56
690
Chehre
D
56
691
Amsterdam
D
56
692
The Number 23
D
56
693
Vivarium
D
56
694
Paper Towns
D
56
695
Eraser
D
56
696
Sikandar Ka Muqaddar
D
56
697
Circle
D
56
698
Killing Ground
D
56
699
Reincarnation
D
56
700
The Maid
D
56