Critics' Choice Awards
2 nominations
| Best Adapted Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
| Best Young Actor/Actress |
Abby Ryder Fortson |
Nominee
|
Writers Guild of America Awards
1 nomination
| Best Adapted Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
San Diego Film Critics Society
9 nominations, 5 won
| Best Adapted Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Winner
|
| Best Picture |
Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. |
Winner
|
| Best Supporting Actress |
Rachel McAdams |
Winner
|
| Best Youth Performance (For a performer under the age of 18) |
Abby Ryder Fortson |
Winner
|
| Breakthrough Actor |
Abby Ryder Fortson |
Winner
|
| Best Actress |
Abby Ryder Fortson |
Nominee
|
| Best Comedic Performance |
Abby Ryder Fortson |
Nominee
|
| Best Director |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
| Best Use of Music |
Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. |
Nominee
|
Las Vegas Film Critics Society
5 nominations, 2 won
| Best Family Film |
Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret. |
Winner
|
| Youth in Film (Female) |
Abby Ryder Fortson |
Winner
|
| Best Adapted Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Actress |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
| Youth in Film (Female) |
Elle Graham |
Nominee
|
Astra Film and Creative Awards
4 nominations, 2 won
| Best Comedy Feature |
Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. |
Winner
|
| Star on the Rise Award |
Abby Ryder Fortson |
Winner
|
| Best Adapted Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Actress |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
Dorian Awards
2 nominations, 1 won
| Unsung Film of the Year |
Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. |
Winner
|
| Best Supporting Film Performance of the Year |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
Florida Film Critics Circle Awards
2 nominations, 1 won
| Best Supporting Actress |
Rachel McAdams |
Winner
|
| Best Adapted Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
Artios Awards
1 nomination, 1 won
| Outstanding Achievement in Casting – Big Budget Feature (Comedy) |
Francine Maisler, Melissa Kostenbauder, Betsy Fippinger, Tara Feldstein, Chase Paris, Molly Rose |
Winner
|
Heartland Film Festival
1 nomination, 1 won
| Truly Moving Picture Award |
Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. |
Winner
|
Kansas City Film Critics Circle
1 nomination, 1 won
| Best Adapted Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Winner
|
Los Angeles Film Critics Association
1 nomination, 1 won
| Best Supporting Performance |
Rachel McAdams |
Winner
|
Phoenix Film Critics Society
1 nomination, 1 won
| Best Performance by a Youth |
Abby Ryder-Fortson |
Winner
|
Hollywood Critics Association Midseason Film Awards
4 nominations
| Best Director |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
| Best Picture |
Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. |
Nominee
|
| Best Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Actress |
Kathy Bates |
Nominee
|
Indiana Film Journalists Association
4 nominations
| Best Adapted Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
| Best Ensemble Acting |
Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret. |
Nominee
|
| Best Film |
Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret. |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Performance |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
Austin Film Critics Association
3 nominations
| Best Adapted Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Actress |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
| The Robert R. "Bobby" McCurdy Memorial Breakthrough Artist Award |
Abby Ryder Forston |
Nominee
|
Chicago Film Critics Association Awards
3 nominations
| Best Adapted Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Actress |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
| Most Promising Performer |
Abby Ryder Fortson |
Nominee
|
Georgia Film Critics Association
3 nominations
| Best Adapted Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Actress |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
| Breakthrough Award |
Abby Ryder Forston |
Nominee
|
Houston Film Critics Society
2 nominations
| Best Picture |
Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Actress |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
North Texas Film Critics Association
2 nominations
| Best Newcomer |
Abby Ryder-Fortson |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Actress |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
Seattle Film Critics Society
2 nominations
| Best Supporting Actress |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
| Best Youth Performance |
Abby Ryder Forston |
Nominee
|
St. Louis Film Critics Association
2 nominations
| Best Adapted Screenplay |
Kelly Fremon Craig |
Nominee
|
| Best Comedy |
Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. |
Nominee
|
Alliance of Women Film Journalists
1 nomination
| Best Woman's Breakthrough Performance |
Abby Ryder Forston |
Nominee
|
Denver Film Critics Society
1 nomination
| Best Supporting Performance by an Actor, Female |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
Gotham Independent Film Awards
1 nomination
| Outstanding Supporting Performance |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
People's Choice Awards
1 nomination
| The Comedy Movie of the Year |
Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. |
Nominee
|
San Francisco Bay Area Film Critics Circle
1 nomination
| Best Supporting Actress |
Rachel McAdams |
Nominee
|
Set Decorators Society of America Awards
1 nomination
| Best Achievement in Décor/Design of a Comedy or Musical Feature Film |
Selina M. Van den Brink and Steve Saklad |
Nominee
|
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association Awards
1 nomination
| Best Youth Performance |
Abby Ryder Fortson |
Nominee
|