Independent Spirit Awards
4 nominations, 2 won
| Best Debut Performance |
Aaron Eckhart |
Winner
|
| Best First Screenplay |
Neil LaBute |
Winner
|
| Best Female Lead |
Stacy Edwards |
Nominee
|
| Best First Feature |
Neil LaBute, Mark Archer, Stephen Pevner |
Nominee
|
Sundance Film Festival
2 nominations, 1 won
| Filmmaker's Trophy |
Neil LaBute |
Winner
|
| Grand Jury Prize |
Neil LaBute |
Nominee
|
Deauville Film Festival
3 nominations, 2 won
| Fun Radio Trophy |
Neil LaBute |
Winner
|
| Jury Special Prize |
Neil LaBute |
Winner
|
| Grand Special Prize |
Neil LaBute |
Nominee
|
Taormina International Film Festival
2 nominations, 2 won
| Best Actor |
Aaron Eckhart |
Winner
|
| Best Actress |
Stacy Edwards |
Winner
|
Edinburgh International Film Festival
1 nomination, 1 won
| Channel 4 Director's Award – Special Mention |
Neil LaBute |
Winner
|
National Board of Review Awards
1 nomination, 1 won
| Special Recognition for Excellence in Filmmaking |
|
Winner
|
New York Film Critics Circle Awards
1 nomination, 1 won
| Best First Film |
Neil LaBute |
Winner
|
Satellite Awards
1 nomination, 1 won
| Special Achievement Award for Outstanding New Talent |
Aaron Eckhart |
Winner
|
Chicago Film Critics Association Awards
2 nominations
| Most Promising Actor |
Aaron Eckhart |
Nominee
|
| Most Promising Actress |
Stacy Edwards |
Nominee
|
Thessaloniki International Film Festival
1 nomination
| Golden Alexander |
Neil LaBute |
Nominee
|