Independent Spirit Awards
2 nominations, 2 won
| Best First Feature |
Robert Eggers, Daniel Bekerman, Jay Van Hoy, Lars Knudsen, Jodi Redmond and Rodrigo Teixeira |
Winner
|
| Best First Screenplay |
Robert Eggers |
Winner
|
Sundance Film Festival
2 nominations, 1 won
| Directing Award |
Robert Eggers |
Winner
|
| Grand Jury Prize |
Robert Eggers |
Nominee
|
Critics Choice Awards
1 nomination
| Best Sci-Fi/Horror Movie |
The Witch |
Nominee
|
Fangoria Chainsaw Awards
4 nominations, 2 won
| Best Actress |
Anya Taylor-Joy |
Winner
|
| Best Film |
The Witch |
Winner
|
| Best Score |
Mark Korven |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Actor |
Ralph Ineson |
Nominee
|
Golden Trailer Awards
3 nominations, 2 won
| Best Horror |
"Family" |
Winner
|
| Best Sound Editing in a TV Spot |
"Paranoia" |
Winner
|
| Best Horror TV Spot |
"Life" |
Nominee
|
Empire Awards
2 nominations, 2 won
| Best Female Newcomer |
Anya Taylor-Joy |
Winner
|
| Best Horror |
The Witch |
Winner
|
Seattle Film Critics Society
7 nominations, 1 won
| Best Youth Performance |
Anya Taylor-Joy |
Winner
|
| Best Cinematography |
Jarin Blaschke |
Nominee
|
| Best Costume Design |
Linda Muir |
Nominee
|
| Best Director |
Robert Eggers |
Nominee
|
| Best Picture of the Year |
The Witch |
Nominee
|
| Best Villain |
Charlie and Wahab Chaudary (as Black Phillip) |
Nominee
|
| Best Youth Performance |
Harvey Scrimshaw |
Nominee
|
Austin Film Critics Association
2 nominations, 1 won
| Best First Film |
The Witch |
Winner
|
| Breakthrough Artist Award |
Anya Taylor-Joy |
Nominee
|
Chicago Film Critics Association
2 nominations, 1 won
| Most Promising Filmmaker |
Robert Eggers |
Winner
|
| Best Art Direction |
The Witch |
Nominee
|
Gotham Awards
2 nominations, 1 won
| Breakthrough Actor |
Anya Taylor-Joy |
Winner
|
| Bingham Ray Breakthrough Director Award |
Robert Eggers |
Nominee
|
Boston Society of Film Critics
1 nomination, 1 won
| Best New Filmmaker |
Robert Eggers |
Winner
|
Bram Stoker Awards
1 nomination, 1 won
| Superior Achievement in a Screenplay |
Robert Eggers |
Winner
|
Festival international du film fantastique de Gérardmer
1 nomination, 1 won
| Prix du jury SyFy |
The Witch |
Winner
|
Golden Tomato Awards
1 nomination, 1 won
| Best Horror Movie 2016 |
The Witch |
Winner
|
London Film Festival
1 nomination, 1 won
| Sutherland Award |
Robert Eggers |
Winner
|
New York Film Critics Online
1 nomination, 1 won
| Best Debut Director |
Robert Eggers |
Winner
|
St. Louis Gateway Film Critics Association
1 nomination, 1 won
| Best Horror/Science-Fiction Film |
The Witch |
Winner
|
Toronto Film Critics Association
1 nomination, 1 won
| Best First Feature |
The Witch |
Winner
|
Saturn Awards
2 nominations
| Best Horror Film |
The Witch |
Nominee
|
| Best Performance by a Younger Actor |
Anya Taylor-Joy |
Nominee
|
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association
2 nominations
| Best Art Direction |
Craig Lathrop |
Nominee
|
| Best Youth Performance |
Anya Taylor-Joy |
Nominee
|
London Film Critics' Circle
1 nomination
| Young British/Irish Performer of the Year |
Anya Taylor-Joy (also for Morgan and Split ) |
Nominee
|
Online Film Critics Society
1 nomination
| Best Picture |
The Witch |
Nominee
|
San Diego Film Critics Society
1 nomination
| Breakthrough Artist |
Anya Taylor-Joy |
Nominee
|
San Francisco Film Critics Circle
1 nomination
| Best Production Design |
Craig Lathrop |
Nominee
|