Highest Rated Mystery Movies
Every movie below is scored by averaging its rating on every platform that carries it — IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Letterboxd, Google and more — into one number out of 100. Only titles rated by at least three platforms are ranked.
301
The Medium
C
69
302
Chip 'n Dale: Rescue Rangers
C
69
303
Saw X
C
69
304
The X Files
C
69
305
The Autopsy of Jane Doe
C
69
306
The Dark Mirror
C
69
307
Unlocked
C
69
308
The Manchurian Candidate
C
69
309
The Girl in the Fog
C
69
310
In the Valley of Elah
C
69
311
Te3n
C
69
312
Arlington Road
C
69
313
Body Double
C
69
314
Barbarian
C
69
315
Day of the Dead
C
69
316
The Vast of Night
C
69
317
Black Coal, Thin Ice
C
69
318
Good Boy
C
69
319
Haseen Dillruba
C
69
320
Judex
C
69
321
State of Play
C
69
322
Blow the Man Down
C
69
323
Satan's Rhapsody
C
68
324
Coma
C
68
325
Home for Rent
C
68
326
The Forbidden Door
C
68
327
Young Sherlock Holmes
C
68
328
Frequencies
C
68
329
K-PAX
C
68
330
The Good Nurse
C
68
331
Karthik Calling Karthik
C
68
332
Bubba Ho-tep
C
68
333
Kill the Messenger
C
68
334
Courage Under Fire
C
68
335
Satan's Slaves 2: Communion
C
68
336
Noroi
C
68
337
Where the Crawdads Sing
C
68
338
Spider
C
68
339
The Score
C
68
340
It Follows
C
68
341
The Actor
C
68
342
Stir of Echoes
C
68
343
Marrowbone
C
68
344
Tom at the Farm
C
68
345
Hope
C
68
346
The Sign of Four
C
68
347
Midsommar
C
68
348
The Queen of Black Magic
C
68
349
Cube
C
68
350
Everybody Knows
C
68
351
Memoria
C
68
352
Frantic
C
68
353
Photographing Fairies
C
68
354
Fletch
C
68
355
Black Bag
C
67
356
The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's Nest
C
67
357
The Maze Runner
C
67
358
Prometheus
C
67
359
Pulse
C
67
360
13B: Fear Has a New Address
C
67
361
A Simple Favor
C
67
362
The Hunters
C
67
363
The Killing of a Sacred Deer
C
67
364
Trash
C
67
365
Detective Dee and the Mystery of the Phantom Flame
C
67
366
Backrooms
C
67
367
Saint Maud
C
67
368
Cocoon
C
67
369
Us
C
67
370
Blink Twice
C
67
371
The Accountant 2
C
67
372
The Story of Marie and Julien
C
67
373
Smile 2
C
67
374
The Wonder
C
67
375
The Translators
C
67
376
Disturbia
C
67
377
Enola Holmes
C
67
378
It Ends
C
67
379
Inherent Vice
C
67
380
1408
C
67
381
Non-Stop
C
67
382
Gonjiam: Haunted Asylum
C
67
383
Black Mirror: Bandersnatch
C
67
384
Sound of My Voice
C
67
385
The Adjuster
C
67
386
Small Town Crime
C
67
387
The Extraordinary Adventures of Adèle Blanc-Sec
C
67
388
The Girl Who Got Away
C
66
389
The Other
C
66
390
Goodnight Mommy
C
66
391
The Turkish Gambit
C
66
392
New Nightmare
C
66
393
False Trail
C
66
394
Confess, Fletch
C
66
395
Fear Street: 1994
C
66
396
Huesera: The Bone Woman
C
66
397
I Am Not a Serial Killer
C
66
398
Trance
C
66
399
Zero Effect
C
66
400
Hit: The First Case
C
66
The Medium
C
69
302
Chip 'n Dale: Rescue Rangers
C
69
303
Saw X
C
69
304
The X Files
C
69
305
The Autopsy of Jane Doe
C
69
306
The Dark Mirror
C
69
307
Unlocked
C
69
308
The Manchurian Candidate
C
69
309
The Girl in the Fog
C
69
310
In the Valley of Elah
C
69
311
Te3n
C
69
312
Arlington Road
C
69
313
Body Double
C
69
314
Barbarian
C
69
315
Day of the Dead
C
69
316
The Vast of Night
C
69
317
Black Coal, Thin Ice
C
69
318
Good Boy
C
69
319
Haseen Dillruba
C
69
320
Judex
C
69
321
State of Play
C
69
322
Blow the Man Down
C
69
323
Satan's Rhapsody
C
68
324
Coma
C
68
325
Home for Rent
C
68
326
The Forbidden Door
C
68
327
Young Sherlock Holmes
C
68
328
Frequencies
C
68
329
K-PAX
C
68
330
The Good Nurse
C
68
331
Karthik Calling Karthik
C
68
332
Bubba Ho-tep
C
68
333
Kill the Messenger
C
68
334
Courage Under Fire
C
68
335
Satan's Slaves 2: Communion
C
68
336
Noroi
C
68
337
Where the Crawdads Sing
C
68
338
Spider
C
68
339
The Score
C
68
340
It Follows
C
68
341
The Actor
C
68
342
Stir of Echoes
C
68
343
Marrowbone
C
68
344
Tom at the Farm
C
68
345
Hope
C
68
346
The Sign of Four
C
68
347
Midsommar
C
68
348
The Queen of Black Magic
C
68
349
Cube
C
68
350
Everybody Knows
C
68
351
Memoria
C
68
352
Frantic
C
68
353
Photographing Fairies
C
68
354
Fletch
C
68
355
Black Bag
C
67
356
The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's Nest
C
67
357
The Maze Runner
C
67
358
Prometheus
C
67
359
Pulse
C
67
360
13B: Fear Has a New Address
C
67
361
A Simple Favor
C
67
362
The Hunters
C
67
363
The Killing of a Sacred Deer
C
67
364
Trash
C
67
365
Detective Dee and the Mystery of the Phantom Flame
C
67
366
Backrooms
C
67
367
Saint Maud
C
67
368
Cocoon
C
67
369
Us
C
67
370
Blink Twice
C
67
371
The Accountant 2
C
67
372
The Story of Marie and Julien
C
67
373
Smile 2
C
67
374
The Wonder
C
67
375
The Translators
C
67
376
Disturbia
C
67
377
Enola Holmes
C
67
378
It Ends
C
67
379
Inherent Vice
C
67
380
1408
C
67
381
Non-Stop
C
67
382
Gonjiam: Haunted Asylum
C
67
383
Black Mirror: Bandersnatch
C
67
384
Sound of My Voice
C
67
385
The Adjuster
C
67
386
Small Town Crime
C
67
387
The Extraordinary Adventures of Adèle Blanc-Sec
C
67
388
The Girl Who Got Away
C
66
389
The Other
C
66
390
Goodnight Mommy
C
66
391
The Turkish Gambit
C
66
392
New Nightmare
C
66
393
False Trail
C
66
394
Confess, Fletch
C
66
395
Fear Street: 1994
C
66
396
Huesera: The Bone Woman
C
66
397
I Am Not a Serial Killer
C
66
398
Trance
C
66
399
Zero Effect
C
66
400
Hit: The First Case
C
66