Highest Rated Mystery Movies
Every movie below is scored by averaging its rating on every platform that carries it — IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Letterboxd, Google and more — into one number out of 100. Only titles rated by at least three platforms are ranked.
401
Enemy
C
66
402
Black Christmas
C
66
403
Shirley
C
66
404
The Pledge
C
66
405
Basic Instinct
C
66
406
You're Next
C
66
407
Crimson Peak
C
66
408
Dorm
C
66
409
Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil
C
66
410
Copycat
C
66
411
The Professor and the Madman
C
66
412
Angel of Mine
C
66
413
Summer of 84
C
65
414
The Art of Self-Defense
C
65
415
What Happened to Monday
C
65
416
The Witch: Part 2. The Other One
C
65
417
Oblivion
C
65
418
Vanilla Sky
C
65
419
Jagga Jasoos
C
65
420
See How They Run
C
65
421
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark
C
65
422
Hunting Season
C
65
423
The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus
C
65
424
The Deep End
C
65
425
TransSiberian
C
65
426
From Hell
C
65
427
National Treasure
C
65
428
The Long Kiss Goodnight
C
65
429
Through the Glass Darkly
C
65
430
Happy Death Day
C
65
431
Joy Ride
C
65
432
The Jacket
C
65
433
The Ring
C
65
434
The Crimson Rivers
C
65
435
Sinister
C
65
436
The Salton Sea
C
65
437
The Entity
C
65
438
Smile
C
65
439
K-19: The Widowmaker
C
65
440
It's What's Inside
C
65
441
Proof
C
65
442
The Thursday Murder Club
C
65
443
Nerve
C
65
444
Watcher
C
65
445
The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It
C
64
446
Thanksgiving
C
64
447
Psycho II
C
64
448
The Blair Witch Project
C
64
449
Scream 2
C
64
450
A Dark Song
C
64
451
Red Eye
C
64
452
Confidence
C
64
453
Kafka
C
64
454
The Night House
C
64
455
The Dead Girl
C
64
456
Resolution
C
64
457
The Pale Blue Eye
C
64
458
Deva
C
64
459
True Crime
C
64
460
Ring
C
64
461
Hunter Hunter
C
64
462
Hail, Caesar!
C
64
463
A Private Life
C
64
464
A Haunting in Venice
C
64
465
Time Lapse
C
64
466
Sleeping Dogs
C
64
467
Conspiracy Theory
C
63
468
Sommersby
C
63
469
Shadows and Fog
C
63
470
The Wrecking Crew
C
63
471
I'm Thinking of Ending Things
C
63
472
Pontypool
C
63
473
Vikrant Rona
C
63
474
Unknown
C
63
475
Kimi
C
63
476
Dead End
C
63
477
The Clovehitch Killer
C
63
478
Drop
C
63
479
Daniel Isn't Real
C
63
480
Puncture
C
63
481
Unlawful Entry
C
63
482
Cuttputlli
C
63
483
Infinity Chamber
C
63
484
Scream
C
63
485
The End of Oak Street
C
63
486
Shutter
C
63
487
Dark Water
C
63
488
Stonehearst Asylum
C
63
489
Nymphomaniac: Vol. II
C
63
490
The House of the Devil
C
63
491
The Thirteenth Floor
C
62
492
The Overnight
C
62
493
Gorky Park
C
62
494
Ace Ventura: Pet Detective
C
62
495
Color Out of Space
C
62
496
Risen
C
62
497
Lights Out
C
62
498
Wicker Park
C
62
499
Stay
C
62
500
Exam
C
62
Enemy
C
66
402
Black Christmas
C
66
403
Shirley
C
66
404
The Pledge
C
66
405
Basic Instinct
C
66
406
You're Next
C
66
407
Crimson Peak
C
66
408
Dorm
C
66
409
Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil
C
66
410
Copycat
C
66
411
The Professor and the Madman
C
66
412
Angel of Mine
C
66
413
Summer of 84
C
65
414
The Art of Self-Defense
C
65
415
What Happened to Monday
C
65
416
The Witch: Part 2. The Other One
C
65
417
Oblivion
C
65
418
Vanilla Sky
C
65
419
Jagga Jasoos
C
65
420
See How They Run
C
65
421
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark
C
65
422
Hunting Season
C
65
423
The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus
C
65
424
The Deep End
C
65
425
TransSiberian
C
65
426
From Hell
C
65
427
National Treasure
C
65
428
The Long Kiss Goodnight
C
65
429
Through the Glass Darkly
C
65
430
Happy Death Day
C
65
431
Joy Ride
C
65
432
The Jacket
C
65
433
The Ring
C
65
434
The Crimson Rivers
C
65
435
Sinister
C
65
436
The Salton Sea
C
65
437
The Entity
C
65
438
Smile
C
65
439
K-19: The Widowmaker
C
65
440
It's What's Inside
C
65
441
Proof
C
65
442
The Thursday Murder Club
C
65
443
Nerve
C
65
444
Watcher
C
65
445
The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It
C
64
446
Thanksgiving
C
64
447
Psycho II
C
64
448
The Blair Witch Project
C
64
449
Scream 2
C
64
450
A Dark Song
C
64
451
Red Eye
C
64
452
Confidence
C
64
453
Kafka
C
64
454
The Night House
C
64
455
The Dead Girl
C
64
456
Resolution
C
64
457
The Pale Blue Eye
C
64
458
Deva
C
64
459
True Crime
C
64
460
Ring
C
64
461
Hunter Hunter
C
64
462
Hail, Caesar!
C
64
463
A Private Life
C
64
464
A Haunting in Venice
C
64
465
Time Lapse
C
64
466
Sleeping Dogs
C
64
467
Conspiracy Theory
C
63
468
Sommersby
C
63
469
Shadows and Fog
C
63
470
The Wrecking Crew
C
63
471
I'm Thinking of Ending Things
C
63
472
Pontypool
C
63
473
Vikrant Rona
C
63
474
Unknown
C
63
475
Kimi
C
63
476
Dead End
C
63
477
The Clovehitch Killer
C
63
478
Drop
C
63
479
Daniel Isn't Real
C
63
480
Puncture
C
63
481
Unlawful Entry
C
63
482
Cuttputlli
C
63
483
Infinity Chamber
C
63
484
Scream
C
63
485
The End of Oak Street
C
63
486
Shutter
C
63
487
Dark Water
C
63
488
Stonehearst Asylum
C
63
489
Nymphomaniac: Vol. II
C
63
490
The House of the Devil
C
63
491
The Thirteenth Floor
C
62
492
The Overnight
C
62
493
Gorky Park
C
62
494
Ace Ventura: Pet Detective
C
62
495
Color Out of Space
C
62
496
Risen
C
62
497
Lights Out
C
62
498
Wicker Park
C
62
499
Stay
C
62
500
Exam
C
62