Highest Rated Mystery Movies
Every movie below is scored by averaging its rating on every platform that carries it — IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Letterboxd, Google and more — into one number out of 100. Only titles rated by at least three platforms are ranked.
501
Sick
C
62
502
Salt
C
62
503
Narrow Margin
C
62
504
Murder on the Orient Express
C
62
505
Life
C
62
506
American Gigolo
C
62
507
Censor
C
62
508
Super Troopers
C
62
509
Boston Strangler
C
62
510
Hallow Road
C
62
511
Young Soul Rebels
C
62
512
The Mystery of the Yellow Room
C
62
513
Enigma
C
62
514
Wild Things
C
62
515
Longlegs
C
62
516
A Walk Among the Tombstones
C
62
517
Spartan
C
62
518
Gerry
C
62
519
The Ritual
C
62
520
Under the Silver Lake
C
62
521
The Commuter
C
62
522
Hoodwinked!
C
62
523
Wrong
C
62
524
Apostle
C
62
525
Odd Thomas
C
62
526
Detective Chinatown 1900
C
62
527
Mystery Team
C
62
528
Triage
C
62
529
Death Note
C
62
530
Secret Window
C
62
531
Reptile
C
62
532
Come to Daddy
C
61
533
Star Trek: The Motion Picture
C
61
534
The Bone Collector
C
61
535
The Limehouse Golem
C
61
536
Don't Let Go
C
61
537
The Skeleton Key
C
61
538
The Invisible Guardian
C
61
539
Edge of Darkness
C
61
540
Caveat
C
61
541
Shaft
C
61
542
Scream 4
C
61
543
Crooked House
C
61
544
The Family Fang
C
61
545
The Ninth Gate
C
61
546
National Treasure: Book of Secrets
C
61
547
High Tension
C
61
548
Hell House LLC
C
61
549
Angels & Demons
C
61
550
Enduring Love
C
61
551
Personal Shopper
C
61
552
The Vigil
C
61
553
OtherLife
C
61
554
Berlin Syndrome
C
61
555
The Village
C
61
556
Secuestro
C
61
557
What Lies Beneath
C
60
558
Paranormal Activity
C
60
559
The Chalk Line
C
60
560
Hollywoodland
C
60
561
Cracks
C
60
562
Uncharted
C
60
563
A Perfect Getaway
C
60
564
Bodies Bodies Bodies
C
60
565
VidaaMuyarchi
C
60
566
Silent Hill
C
60
567
Luther: The Fallen Sun
C
60
568
No Exit
C
60
569
The Book of Vision
C
60
570
Greedy People
C
60
571
Kiss the Girls
C
60
572
Master Gardener
C
60
573
The House with a Clock in Its Walls
C
60
574
Event Horizon
C
60
575
Free Fire
C
60
576
Tomorrowland
C
60
577
Luckiest Girl Alive
C
60
578
The Awakening
C
60
579
Pacific Heights
C
60
580
Death on the Nile
C
60
581
Malignant
C
60
582
Cherish
C
60
583
The Void
C
60
584
Cruising
C
60
585
Entrapment
C
60
586
Grabbers
C
60
587
Revelations
C
60
588
Final Destination 2
D
59
589
Starry Eyes
D
59
590
Fire in the Sky
D
59
591
Relic
D
59
592
Eagle Eye
D
59
593
Buster's Mal Heart
D
59
594
Double Jeopardy
D
59
595
Reflet dans un diamant mort
D
59
596
Blood Work
D
59
597
Scoop
D
59
598
The Da Vinci Code
D
59
599
Escape Room
D
59
600
Next Door
D
59
Sick
C
62
502
Salt
C
62
503
Narrow Margin
C
62
504
Murder on the Orient Express
C
62
505
Life
C
62
506
American Gigolo
C
62
507
Censor
C
62
508
Super Troopers
C
62
509
Boston Strangler
C
62
510
Hallow Road
C
62
511
Young Soul Rebels
C
62
512
The Mystery of the Yellow Room
C
62
513
Enigma
C
62
514
Wild Things
C
62
515
Longlegs
C
62
516
A Walk Among the Tombstones
C
62
517
Spartan
C
62
518
Gerry
C
62
519
The Ritual
C
62
520
Under the Silver Lake
C
62
521
The Commuter
C
62
522
Hoodwinked!
C
62
523
Wrong
C
62
524
Apostle
C
62
525
Odd Thomas
C
62
526
Detective Chinatown 1900
C
62
527
Mystery Team
C
62
528
Triage
C
62
529
Death Note
C
62
530
Secret Window
C
62
531
Reptile
C
62
532
Come to Daddy
C
61
533
Star Trek: The Motion Picture
C
61
534
The Bone Collector
C
61
535
The Limehouse Golem
C
61
536
Don't Let Go
C
61
537
The Skeleton Key
C
61
538
The Invisible Guardian
C
61
539
Edge of Darkness
C
61
540
Caveat
C
61
541
Shaft
C
61
542
Scream 4
C
61
543
Crooked House
C
61
544
The Family Fang
C
61
545
The Ninth Gate
C
61
546
National Treasure: Book of Secrets
C
61
547
High Tension
C
61
548
Hell House LLC
C
61
549
Angels & Demons
C
61
550
Enduring Love
C
61
551
Personal Shopper
C
61
552
The Vigil
C
61
553
OtherLife
C
61
554
Berlin Syndrome
C
61
555
The Village
C
61
556
Secuestro
C
61
557
What Lies Beneath
C
60
558
Paranormal Activity
C
60
559
The Chalk Line
C
60
560
Hollywoodland
C
60
561
Cracks
C
60
562
Uncharted
C
60
563
A Perfect Getaway
C
60
564
Bodies Bodies Bodies
C
60
565
VidaaMuyarchi
C
60
566
Silent Hill
C
60
567
Luther: The Fallen Sun
C
60
568
No Exit
C
60
569
The Book of Vision
C
60
570
Greedy People
C
60
571
Kiss the Girls
C
60
572
Master Gardener
C
60
573
The House with a Clock in Its Walls
C
60
574
Event Horizon
C
60
575
Free Fire
C
60
576
Tomorrowland
C
60
577
Luckiest Girl Alive
C
60
578
The Awakening
C
60
579
Pacific Heights
C
60
580
Death on the Nile
C
60
581
Malignant
C
60
582
Cherish
C
60
583
The Void
C
60
584
Cruising
C
60
585
Entrapment
C
60
586
Grabbers
C
60
587
Revelations
C
60
588
Final Destination 2
D
59
589
Starry Eyes
D
59
590
Fire in the Sky
D
59
591
Relic
D
59
592
Eagle Eye
D
59
593
Buster's Mal Heart
D
59
594
Double Jeopardy
D
59
595
Reflet dans un diamant mort
D
59
596
Blood Work
D
59
597
Scoop
D
59
598
The Da Vinci Code
D
59
599
Escape Room
D
59
600
Next Door
D
59