Highest Rated Mystery Movies
Every movie below is scored by averaging its rating on every platform that carries it — IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Letterboxd, Google and more — into one number out of 100. Only titles rated by at least three platforms are ranked.
201
Hereditary
B
73
202
Thunderheart
B
73
203
The Spanish Prisoner
B
73
204
Sherlock Holmes
B
73
205
Sleepy Hollow
B
73
206
Thursday
B
73
207
Angel Heart
B
73
208
Tenebrae
B
73
209
Detective Byomkesh Bakshy!
B
73
210
Watchmen
B
73
211
The Ghost Writer
B
73
212
Thelma
B
73
213
Photocopier
B
73
214
Bloody Hell
B
73
215
Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows
B
72
216
The White Tiger
B
72
217
God's Crooked Lines
B
72
218
Pig
B
72
219
Let Me In
B
72
220
Naruto Shippuden the Movie: Blood Prison
B
72
221
The Dry
B
72
222
Bugsy
B
72
223
Amistad
B
72
224
A Tale of Two Sisters
B
72
225
Cows
B
72
226
Lucky Number Slevin
B
72
227
Clue
B
72
228
The Trouble with Harry
B
72
229
The Return of the Pink Panther
B
72
230
Devil in a Blue Dress
B
72
231
Breakdown
B
72
232
Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery
B
72
233
Videodrome
B
72
234
Terkel in Trouble
B
72
235
Department Q: A Conspiracy of Faith
B
72
236
Identity
B
72
237
The Kid Detective
B
72
238
Time
B
71
239
Suicide Room
B
71
240
Dressed to Kill
B
71
241
Limitless
B
71
242
Affliction
B
71
243
Caddo Lake
B
71
244
Bad Times at the El Royale
B
71
245
Wicked Little Letters
B
71
246
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy
B
71
247
The Hands of Orlac
B
71
248
Get Low
B
71
249
Keane
B
71
250
Marnie
B
71
251
Game Night
B
71
252
Saw
B
71
253
Last Night in Soho
B
71
254
Broken Flowers
B
71
255
Oddity
B
71
256
They Cloned Tyrone
B
71
257
The Gift
B
71
258
Vengeance
B
71
259
Clockers
B
71
260
A Small September Affair
B
71
261
Six Degrees of Separation
B
71
262
The Artifice Girl
B
71
263
Beasts Clawing at Straws
B
71
264
Unbreakable
B
71
265
Presumed Innocent
B
71
266
Soylent Green
B
71
267
The Treatment
B
70
268
Dead Again
B
70
269
Fear Street: Part Two - 1978
B
70
270
The Keeper of Lost Causes
B
70
271
What We Hide
B
70
272
Enola Holmes 2
B
70
273
Brick
B
70
274
I See You
B
70
275
Inland Empire
B
70
276
Narc
B
70
277
Batman: Hush
B
70
278
The Housemaid
B
70
279
The Witch
B
70
280
Murder by Death
B
70
281
Super 8
B
70
282
Satan's Slaves
B
70
283
Final Destination Bloodlines
B
70
284
Death Note: The Last Name
B
70
285
The Body
B
70
286
In the Mouth of Madness
B
70
287
Impetigore
B
70
288
The Cabin in the Woods
B
70
289
The Unknown Woman
B
70
290
Mr. Monk's Last Case: A Monk Movie
B
70
291
Mr. Holmes
B
70
292
8 Women
B
70
293
The Firm
B
70
294
Saboteur
B
70
295
Exit 8
B
70
296
The Girl Who Played with Fire
B
70
297
Goodbye
B
70
298
The Client
C
69
299
Fear Street: Part Three - 1666
C
69
300
The Guest
C
69
Hereditary
B
73
202
Thunderheart
B
73
203
The Spanish Prisoner
B
73
204
Sherlock Holmes
B
73
205
Sleepy Hollow
B
73
206
Thursday
B
73
207
Angel Heart
B
73
208
Tenebrae
B
73
209
Detective Byomkesh Bakshy!
B
73
210
Watchmen
B
73
211
The Ghost Writer
B
73
212
Thelma
B
73
213
Photocopier
B
73
214
Bloody Hell
B
73
215
Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows
B
72
216
The White Tiger
B
72
217
God's Crooked Lines
B
72
218
Pig
B
72
219
Let Me In
B
72
220
Naruto Shippuden the Movie: Blood Prison
B
72
221
The Dry
B
72
222
Bugsy
B
72
223
Amistad
B
72
224
A Tale of Two Sisters
B
72
225
Cows
B
72
226
Lucky Number Slevin
B
72
227
Clue
B
72
228
The Trouble with Harry
B
72
229
The Return of the Pink Panther
B
72
230
Devil in a Blue Dress
B
72
231
Breakdown
B
72
232
Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery
B
72
233
Videodrome
B
72
234
Terkel in Trouble
B
72
235
Department Q: A Conspiracy of Faith
B
72
236
Identity
B
72
237
The Kid Detective
B
72
238
Time
B
71
239
Suicide Room
B
71
240
Dressed to Kill
B
71
241
Limitless
B
71
242
Affliction
B
71
243
Caddo Lake
B
71
244
Bad Times at the El Royale
B
71
245
Wicked Little Letters
B
71
246
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy
B
71
247
The Hands of Orlac
B
71
248
Get Low
B
71
249
Keane
B
71
250
Marnie
B
71
251
Game Night
B
71
252
Saw
B
71
253
Last Night in Soho
B
71
254
Broken Flowers
B
71
255
Oddity
B
71
256
They Cloned Tyrone
B
71
257
The Gift
B
71
258
Vengeance
B
71
259
Clockers
B
71
260
A Small September Affair
B
71
261
Six Degrees of Separation
B
71
262
The Artifice Girl
B
71
263
Beasts Clawing at Straws
B
71
264
Unbreakable
B
71
265
Presumed Innocent
B
71
266
Soylent Green
B
71
267
The Treatment
B
70
268
Dead Again
B
70
269
Fear Street: Part Two - 1978
B
70
270
The Keeper of Lost Causes
B
70
271
What We Hide
B
70
272
Enola Holmes 2
B
70
273
Brick
B
70
274
I See You
B
70
275
Inland Empire
B
70
276
Narc
B
70
277
Batman: Hush
B
70
278
The Housemaid
B
70
279
The Witch
B
70
280
Murder by Death
B
70
281
Super 8
B
70
282
Satan's Slaves
B
70
283
Final Destination Bloodlines
B
70
284
Death Note: The Last Name
B
70
285
The Body
B
70
286
In the Mouth of Madness
B
70
287
Impetigore
B
70
288
The Cabin in the Woods
B
70
289
The Unknown Woman
B
70
290
Mr. Monk's Last Case: A Monk Movie
B
70
291
Mr. Holmes
B
70
292
8 Women
B
70
293
The Firm
B
70
294
Saboteur
B
70
295
Exit 8
B
70
296
The Girl Who Played with Fire
B
70
297
Goodbye
B
70
298
The Client
C
69
299
Fear Street: Part Three - 1666
C
69
300
The Guest
C
69