Where to watch
Each link opens a search on that service. Checked 13 October 2026.
Streaming data from JustWatch
Anatomy of a Murder
1959
· Movie
· 161 min
A
MEANRANK
85/100
Where it ranks
- Mean Score #111
- IMDb #357
- Google retired #886
- Rotten Tomatoes #71
- Metacritic #73
- Letterboxd #166
+8 more
- Rotten Tomatoes Critics #17
- Rotten Tomatoes Audience #464
- Metacritic Critics #71
- Metacritic Audience #287
- Criticker #125
- Kinopoisk #1138
- AlloCiné #286
- Trakt #521
Every rating
73–100
out of 100
Mostly agreed
Lowest is Criticker on 73, highest is Rotten Tomatoes critics on 100. Critics average 98, everyone else 83.
See the films the platforms disagree about most →A small-town lawyer agrees to defend a military man who claims he murdered another man because he raped his wife. The lawyer must sift through conflicting testimonies and circumstantial evidence to construct a defense for his client. The trial becomes a complex battle of wits against a shrewd prosecuting attorney, where the truth is elusive and the line between justice and manipulation is constantly blurred.
Details
- Director
- Otto Preminger
- Writer
- Wendell Mayes
- Based on
- Anatomy of a Murder by John D. Voelker
- Studio
- Carlyle Productions
- Released
- 1 July 1959
- Country
- United States
- Language
- English
- Runtime
- 161 min
- Rated
- NR
- Budget
- $2.0M
- Box office
- $8.0M
- Awards
- 11 wins, 17 nominations
This title elsewhere
Cast
Full cast (27) →
Awards & nominations
See all 28 →3 major awards won · 11 wins from 28 nominations across 11 ceremonies
| Grammy Awards 1959 | Best Soundtrack Album – Background Score from a Motion Picture or Television | Anatomy of a Murder – Duke Ellington | Winner |
| Grammy Awards 1959 | Best Performance by an Orchestra – for Dancing | Anatomy of a Murder – Duke Ellington | Winner |
| Grammy Awards 1959 | Best Musical Composition First Recorded and Released in 1959 (more than 5 minutes duration) | Anatomy of a Murder – Duke Ellington | Winner |
| Academy Awards 1959 | Best Motion Picture | Otto Preminger | Nominee |
| Academy Awards 1959 | Best Actor | James Stewart | Nominee |
| Academy Awards 1959 | Best Supporting Actor | Arthur O'Connell | Nominee |
| Academy Awards 1959 | Best Supporting Actor | George C. Scott | Nominee |
| Academy Awards 1959 | Best Screenplay – Based on Material from Another Medium | Wendell Mayes | Nominee |
Awards from Wikipedia, CC BY-SA.
More like this
Featured in
All lists →
On this list
16 September 2026
The best courtroom movies: sixteen films about judgement
The hearings, performances and private lives that make a legal decision more than a clever final speech.
29 October 2026
Why Batman works without superpowers—and when the films forget why
Fear, money, detective work and moral limits: four Batman films test what makes Bruce Wayne worth watching.
29 October 2026
Five great directorial debuts, ranked for what is already on screen
Citizen Kane, The 400 Blows, Get Out, Reservoir Dogs and Following: first features judged without borrowing greatness from the careers that followed.
29 October 2026
TV shows with Black female leads: four series worth arguing about
Insecure, Queen Sugar, Scandal and How to Get Away with Murder, ranked for character writing, dramatic range and the lives they make room for.
29 October 2026
Five great TV scores—and the scenes that explain why
Twin Peaks, Succession, Game of Thrones, Westworld and Stranger Things, judged for what their original music does inside the drama.
8 October 2026
Leonardo DiCaprio's films, ranked—and the performances inside them
Twenty-one selected films, with a closer look at the acting: comic timing, self-invention, wounded authority and the effort that sometimes shows.
16 September 2026
The best courtroom movies: sixteen films about judgement
The hearings, performances and private lives that make a legal decision more than a clever final speech.
29 October 2026
Why Batman works without superpowers—and when the films forget why
Fear, money, detective work and moral limits: four Batman films test what makes Bruce Wayne worth watching.
29 October 2026
Five great directorial debuts, ranked for what is already on screen
Citizen Kane, The 400 Blows, Get Out, Reservoir Dogs and Following: first features judged without borrowing greatness from the careers that followed.
29 October 2026
TV shows with Black female leads: four series worth arguing about
Insecure, Queen Sugar, Scandal and How to Get Away with Murder, ranked for character writing, dramatic range and the lives they make room for.
29 October 2026
Five great TV scores—and the scenes that explain why
Twin Peaks, Succession, Game of Thrones, Westworld and Stranger Things, judged for what their original music does inside the drama.
8 October 2026
Leonardo DiCaprio's films, ranked—and the performances inside them
Twenty-one selected films, with a closer look at the acting: comic timing, self-invention, wounded authority and the effort that sometimes shows.
Just released
See all →
Coming soon
Trailer — Anatomy of a Murder
×Full cast — Anatomy of a Murder
×
28 awards — Anatomy of a Murder
×
Grammy Awards
3 nominations, 3 won
| Best Musical Composition First Recorded and Released in 1959 (more than 5 minutes duration) | Anatomy of a Murder – Duke Ellington | Winner |
| Best Performance by an Orchestra – for Dancing | Anatomy of a Murder – Duke Ellington | Winner |
| Best Soundtrack Album – Background Score from a Motion Picture or Television | Anatomy of a Murder – Duke Ellington | Winner |
Academy Awards
7 nominations
| Best Actor | James Stewart | Nominee |
| Best Cinematography – Black-and-White | Sam Leavitt | Nominee |
| Best Film Editing | Louis R. Loeffler | Nominee |
| Best Motion Picture | Otto Preminger | Nominee |
| Best Screenplay – Based on Material from Another Medium | Wendell Mayes | Nominee |
| Best Supporting Actor | Arthur O'Connell | Nominee |
| Best Supporting Actor | George C. Scott | Nominee |
Golden Globe Awards
4 nominations
| Best Actress in a Motion Picture – Drama | Lee Remick | Nominee |
| Best Director – Motion Picture | Otto Preminger | Nominee |
| Best Motion Picture – Drama | Nominee | |
| Best Supporting Actor – Motion Picture | Joseph N. Welch | Nominee |
Directors Guild of America Awards
1 nomination
| Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Motion Pictures | Otto Preminger | Nominee |
Writers Guild of America Awards
1 nomination
| Best Written American Drama | Wendell Mayes | Nominee |
Laurel Awards
3 nominations, 3 won
| Top Drama | Winner | |
| Top Male Dramatic Performance | James Stewart | Winner |
| Top Male Supporting Performance | Arthur O'Connell | Winner |
New York Film Critics Circle Awards
2 nominations, 2 won
| Best Actor | James Stewart | Winner |
| Best Screenplay | Wendell Mayes | Winner |
Venice International Film Festival
2 nominations, 1 won
| Best Actor | James Stewart | Winner |
| Golden Lion | Otto Preminger | Nominee |
National Film Preservation Board
1 nomination, 1 won
| National Film Registry | Winner |
Online Film & Television Association Awards
1 nomination, 1 won
| Hall of Fame – Motion Picture | Winner |
British Academy Film Awards
3 nominations
| Best Film from any Source | Otto Preminger | Nominee |
| Best Foreign Actor | James Stewart | Nominee |
| Most Promising Newcomer to Film | Joseph N. Welch | Nominee |