Independent Spirit Awards
4 nominations, 1 won
| Best Male Lead |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Director |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
| Best Film |
Jack Binder, Greg Clark, Gary Hamilton, Victoria Hill, David Hinojosa, Frank Murray, Deepak Sikka and Christine Vachon |
Nominee
|
| Best Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
Critics' Choice Movie Awards
2 nominations, 1 won
| Best Original Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Winner
|
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Nominee
|
Academy Awards
1 nomination
| Best Original Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
Vancouver Film Critics Circle
4 nominations, 3 won
| Best Actor, Male |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Director |
Paul Schrader |
Winner
|
| Best Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Winner
|
| Best Picture |
First Reformed |
Nominee
|
Chicago Film Critics Association
4 nominations, 2 won
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Original Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Winner
|
| Best Director |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
| Best Picture |
First Reformed |
Nominee
|
Gotham Awards
4 nominations, 2 won
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Winner
|
| Audience Award |
First Reformed |
Nominee
|
| Best Feature |
First Reformed |
Nominee
|
San Francisco Film Critics Circle
4 nominations, 2 won
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Original Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Winner
|
| Best Director |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
| Best Film |
First Reformed |
Nominee
|
National Board of Review
2 nominations, 2 won
| Best Original Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Winner
|
| Top 10 Films |
First Reformed |
Winner
|
New York Film Critics Circle
2 nominations, 2 won
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Winner
|
New York Film Critics Online
2 nominations, 2 won
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Top 10 Films |
First Reformed |
Winner
|
Online Film Critics Society
2 nominations, 2 won
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Original Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Winner
|
Toronto Film Critics Association
2 nominations, 2 won
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Winner
|
Detroit Film Critics Society
4 nominations, 1 won
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Director |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
| Best Picture |
First Reformed |
Nominee
|
| Best Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
Seattle Film Critics Society
4 nominations, 1 won
| Best Actor in a Leading Role |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Director |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
| Best Picture of the Year |
First Reformed |
Nominee
|
| Best Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
London Film Critics' Circle
3 nominations, 1 won
| Actor of the Year |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Film of the Year |
First Reformed |
Nominee
|
| Screenwriter of the Year |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
St. Louis Film Critics Association
3 nominations, 1 won
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Film |
First Reformed |
Nominee
|
| Best Original Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
Alliance of Women Film Journalists
2 nominations, 1 won
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Original Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
San Diego Film Critics Society
2 nominations, 1 won
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
| Best Cinematography |
Alexander Dynan |
Nominee
|
American Film Institute
1 nomination, 1 won
| Top 10 Films of the Year |
First Reformed |
Winner
|
Los Angeles Film Critics Association
1 nomination, 1 won
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Winner
|
Houston Film Critics Society
3 nominations
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Nominee
|
| Best Picture |
First Reformed |
Nominee
|
| Best Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
Satellite Awards
3 nominations
| Best Actor in a Motion Picture, Drama |
Ethan Hawke |
Nominee
|
| Best Independent Film |
First Reformed |
Nominee
|
| Best Original Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|
Los Angeles Online Film Critics Society
2 nominations
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Nominee
|
| Best Independent Film |
First Reformed |
Nominee
|
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association
2 nominations
| Best Actor |
Ethan Hawke |
Nominee
|
| Best Original Screenplay |
Paul Schrader |
Nominee
|