Independent Spirit Awards
5 nominations
| Best Director |
Jane Schoenbrun |
Nominee
|
| Best Feature |
Ali Herting, Sam Intili, Dave McCary, Emma Stone and Sarah Winshall |
Nominee
|
| Best Lead Performance |
Justice Smith |
Nominee
|
| Best Screenplay |
Jane Schoenbrun |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Performance |
Jack Haven |
Nominee
|
Critics' Choice Super Awards
1 nomination
| Best Actor in a Horror Movie |
Justice Smith |
Nominee
|
Dorian Awards
9 nominations, 2 won
| LGBTQ Film of the Year |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Winner
|
| LGBTQ Screenplay of the Year |
Jane Schoenbrun |
Winner
|
| Director of the Year |
Jane Schoenbrun |
Nominee
|
| Film Music of the Year |
Alex G |
Nominee
|
| Film Performance of the Year |
Justice Smith |
Nominee
|
| Film of the Year |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Nominee
|
| Genre Film of the Year |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Nominee
|
| Screenplay of the Year |
Jane Schoenbrun |
Nominee
|
| Supporting Film Performance of the Year |
Jack Haven |
Nominee
|
Fangoria Chainsaw Awards
4 nominations, 1 won
| Best Limited Release |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Winner
|
| Best Cinematography |
Eric K. Yue |
Nominee
|
| Best Score |
Alex G |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Performance |
Jack Haven |
Nominee
|
Florida Film Critics Circle
2 nominations, 1 won
| Best Original Screenplay |
Jane Schoenbrun |
Winner
|
| Breakout Performance |
Jack Haven |
Nominee
|
Champs-Élysées Film Festival
1 nomination, 1 won
| Audience Award for Best American Independent Feature |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Winner
|
Neuchâtel International Fantastic Film Festival
1 nomination, 1 won
| Imaging The Future best production design |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Winner
|
Seattle International Film Festival
1 nomination, 1 won
| Seattle Film Critics Society Feature Film Award |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Winner
|
Astra Midseason Movie Awards
5 nominations
| Best Actor |
Justice Smith |
Nominee
|
| Best Indie |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Nominee
|
| Best Picture |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Nominee
|
| Best Screenplay |
Jane Schoenbrun |
Nominee
|
| Best Supporting Actor |
Jack Haven |
Nominee
|
Chicago Film Critics Association
3 nominations
| Best Director |
Jane Schoenbrun |
Nominee
|
| Best Film |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Nominee
|
| Most Promising Performer |
Jack Haven |
Nominee
|
Gotham Awards
3 nominations
| Best Director |
Jane Schoenbrun |
Nominee
|
| Outstanding Lead Performance |
Justice Smith |
Nominee
|
| Outstanding Supporting Performance |
Jack Haven |
Nominee
|
St. Louis Film Critics Association
2 nominations
| Best Horror Film |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Nominee
|
| Best Soundtrack |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Nominee
|
Black Reel Awards
1 nomination
| Outstanding Independent Film |
Jane Schoenbrun |
Nominee
|
Seattle Film Critics Society
1 nomination
| Best Picture |
I Saw the TV Glow |
Nominee
|