Critics' Choice Movie Awards
2 nominations, 1 won
| Best Young Actor or Actress |
Maisy Stella |
Winner
|
| Best Comedy Film |
My Old Ass |
Nominee
|
Independent Spirit Awards
2 nominations, 1 won
| Best Breakthrough Performance |
Maisy Stella |
Winner
|
| Best Screenplay |
Megan Park |
Nominee
|
Directors Guild of America Awards
1 nomination
| Outstanding Directing – First-Time Feature Film |
Megan Park |
Nominee
|
Writers Guild of America Awards
1 nomination
| Best Original Screenplay |
Megan Park |
Nominee
|
Las Vegas Film Critics Society
2 nominations, 2 won
| Best Comedy |
My Old Ass |
Winner
|
| Best Youth Performance – Female (under 21) |
Maisy Stella |
Winner
|
Artios Awards
1 nomination, 1 won
| Outstanding Achievement in Casting – Feature Studio or Independent (Comedy) |
Douglas Aibel & Matthew Glasner |
Winner
|
GLAAD Media Awards
1 nomination, 1 won
| Outstanding Film – Wide Release |
My Old Ass |
Winner
|
National Board of Review
1 nomination, 1 won
| Top Ten Independent Films |
My Old Ass |
Winner
|
Variety Breakthrough Awards
1 nomination, 1 won
| Breakthrough Artist |
Maddie Ziegler |
Winner
|
Alliance of Women Film Journalists
3 nominations
| Best Breakthrough Performance |
Maisy Stella |
Nominee
|
| Best Woman Director |
Megan Park |
Nominee
|
| Best Woman Screenwriter |
Megan Park |
Nominee
|
Music City Film Critics Association
2 nominations
| Best Comedy Film |
My Old Ass |
Nominee
|
| Best Young Actress |
Maisy Stella |
Nominee
|
Columbus Film Critics Association
1 nomination
| Best Comedy |
My Old Ass |
Nominee
|
Gotham Awards
1 nomination
| Breakthrough Performer |
Maisy Stella |
Nominee
|
Indiana Film Journalists Association
1 nomination
| Breakout of the Year |
Maisy Stella |
Nominee
|
Kansas City Film Critics Circle
1 nomination
| Best LGBT Film |
My Old Ass |
Nominee
|
London Film Critics' Circle
1 nomination
| Breakthrough Performer |
Maisy Stella |
Nominee
|
Michigan Movie Critics Guild
1 nomination
| Breakthrough Award |
Maisy Stella |
Nominee
|
San Diego Film Critics Society Awards
1 nomination
| Best Comedic Performance |
Aubrey Plaza |
Nominee
|
Saturn Awards
1 nomination
| Best Fantasy Film |
My Old Ass |
Nominee
|